Very good lemon chess pie. Good service. Disappointed that they no longer put whip cream on the strawberry pies but oh well
Best pies in Dayton. Drove 2 hours to get my fresh strawberry pie for my birthday
Best ever! Stopped by to pick up pies to bring back to Colorado with us. Snacked on Snails on our ride home. YUMM!!!
I believe your pies are even better now. My family and I have been enjoying them for many, many years. I bought some for Father's Day and wow are they good. Thank you for all the happy and tasty years of nice selection of these very special treats.
Whenever we are in town a stop at Mehaffies is a must. Really love all their pies but our favorite is their cheesecake on a stick. It is the perfect match to a hot summer day.
Lol I feel I should just have a drop off at my house my kiddo loves there turtle cheesecake so much we have to get a cheesecake a week ...
Great service, great cheese cake, even a great pumpkin pie that was on sale and a couple days old! I'll have to go back for more!!! And they have a card that you get punches for every pie you buy at full price you can rack up and I think get a free pie?
I ordered a Dutch Apple pie from a school. I was very disappointed.while the pie itself was ok . It was not a Dutch Apple pie. It was a plain Apple pie with maybe 2 tablespoons of crumble on top. I was very very disappointed
Outstanding! Great customer service! The owner was great. I asked him about ordering online and he said that might happen later in the summer. I grew up in Dayton and moved away years ago. Everytime I come back to visit I make a trip to Mehaffies. You won't find a better quality or better tasting pie.
Great customer service. The apple pie is really good.