Tony's Coneys

5266 W Broad St, Columbus - 43228
219 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Burgers Hot Dogs
(614) 878-7353

Good, quick food. Great shakes and ice cream. Reasonable prices. An overall happy establishment filled with happy, helpful employees.My only dissatisfaction was that they advertise chili but don't sell it in the summer.

Used to be great, however my last experience was horrible. Gave me 2 chicken tenders on a bun and called it a sandwich. Never ordered my food plain. The chili cheese fries were really good but they gave me no fork or napkins. I'm not sure what is going on there but jeez.

Unfortunately, due to low staffing, it seems the employees have to prioritize all Uber eats / door dash orders over walk-in customers. My father and I went there for lunch, and after waiting 30 minutes for someone to take our order, an employee asked us and several others waiting for service if any of us was an Uber order. When we all said no she went back to the kitchen. Hopefully they can hire more staff soon. I love this place. When I grew up in the area we'd go there for coneys and ice cream all the time.

Omg, this is the best burger I’ve ever had. I’ve never been here and ordered a double cheeseburger and let me tell you, it’s every bit of close to 3/4 pound and full of flavor. I will definitely be back. I would have taken a picture but it was gone before i had a chance. I’m all about supporting local businesses and this place is a .

I just want to say few things. I love hot dogs. Every time I eat them I say it’s the best one ever and this was my first time here. The hot dogs tasted so cheap. The rest of the food was okay. But oh my gosh. The wait. They have a drive through a order window and an inside eating area. Three different places to order food yet everyone had to wait an outrageous amount of time to even get anyone to even talk to you. On top of that just sitting in the area you eat ur food. My eyes were burning from the smoke that filled that place. I had to go outside after 10 minutes of sitting there bc I couldn’t keep my eyes open.

Tony's coneys is what dairy queen used to be back in the day when it was a small mom and pop-like place. The coneys are absolutely heaven and their other menu items are so affordable and are full of flavor. Their cheeseburgers are so savory and so are the fried pickles. They also have the most amazing milkshakes...and they should bring "all the boys to the yard." Especially the raspberry one ??‍♀️???

Friendly staff. Really good ice cream. Could use a bigger selection. But still a really good small place to go to. Good priced though

This is my favorite place. It's nostalgic. The menu is simple but anything and everything you can get from here is amazing! The milkshakes are so good!

Lived over on southwest side for 10 years and never been. Decided to give it a try and it was amazing. Customer service was amazing! Food was hot and fresh. Definitely recommend!!

Been eating at Tony's for over 30 years. Just went through the drive thru and got some coneys. Basically zero coney sauce, really, really, really, skimpy ! Something has changed here, not sure I'll be back. Pathetic