The Old Mohawk

819 Mohawk St, Columbus - 43206
226 reviews
American Soup
(614) 444-7204

I've been dining at The Old Mohawk for years. The food has always been excellent, and the staff friendly and professional - except for my most recent visit. The food was still great, but the waitress was surly and quite unprofessional. Hopefully this was just a quirk, and the service will soon return to their former standards.

Amazing food at a great price. They were very busy the day we stopped in but we were seated within minutes. The staff was great.

Great atmosphere right in German Village. Been here forever! There's a reason for that. The bratwurst sandwich was killer. Girlfriend got the veggie wrap and it looked really good. Fries were hot and crisp, but the potato pancakes were even better. Served with a horseradish/mayo that complimented the dish really well. We will be back.

So fun and very cool to see the history.

Nice place that matches the ascetic of the area. They have a sizeable menu with a neighborhood atmosphere. Staff was very nice. I ordered the wings and aside from the size they were actually pretty good. They had a nice crunch to them that improved the eating experience. For the price though the should have been way larger. Had that been the case I'd have given them five stars Maybe it was just the night I went but my friend also got wings and they were also bite size. So if you're hungry I order something else.

Longtime local bar/restaurant. Great bourbon selection and lots of hometown menu options. Tried the turtle soup and meatloaf dinner. Both excellent options. The chocolate cake for dessert was the best.

We were seated promptly and then forgotten. We had to get a waitresses attention for our drinks and then we were told she wasn't our server. A server brought our drinks and took our order or so we thought. 4 couples were seated after us in our area, at varying times. Each received their food immediately. Finally, we just asked for our bill. . A waiter showed up with our order as we were leaving. I sent it back. I don't recommend this restaurant at all!!

As always, great food and great service!

Our dinner at old Mohawk left a lot to be desired. This was the first true date night for my husband and I in a very long time and it was pretty disappointing. The service at old Mohawk gets 5 stars. However, the food would be a 2 at best. The spinach dip appetizer was cold, soupy and lacked flavor. My husbands burger came out as pictured. The top bun was put in a pool of the myoglobin from the burger which was quite nasty. I got the meatloaf dinner and it was not good at all. The meatloaf was dry and the mashed potatoes were lumpy. It was on par with the meatloaf lunch you’d be served in grade school. The macaroni and cheese (pictured) had over cooked bread crumbs on the top and was runny as well. Not much different in flavor than what you would expect from a stoffers meal. I had high hopes for the old Mohawk but sadly this place missed the mark.

All the food was excellent. Love the sweet potatoe tater tots and gouda bites were a love. Our waitress was so nice and attentive. Our toddler said more marinara please! Lol