Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

2158 E Main St, Columbus - 43209
336 reviews
American Pubs Comfort Food
(614) 236-2426

We were a group of eight women celebrating our friendship. When I made the reservation for 8 through OpenTable, it was confirmed to be a high-top table. I added a special request for a low-top table. We were greeted enthusiastically and I was elated to find the staff had fulfilled my request for a low-top table. One of our party is confined to a wheelchair and we were so grateful for the accommodation. Our server, Nick, was outstanding. He was attentive, fun, knowledgeable and answered every question. He made sure that those of us asking for modifications on the menu were satisfied. The cocktails were delicious, and our food was prepared to perfection. We thoroughly enjoyed ourselves and superlative quality experience that Rusty Bucket provided.

Great service. Good food.

Always great food. Love the salads!!!

Wonderful restaurant! We took a shot int the dark since we didn’t know the area and hit the jackpot. The food was wonderful. The staff superb. It was my niece’s birthday and my mom and sisters and nieces had a girls weekend. This was the icing on the cake. Thanks so much for making it extra special!

Great service! Our server was fast, friendly and always on top of things like refills.

It was my brothers 16 birthday and we tried the RB for the first time. Our server Ryan had some great recommendations and we absolutely loved everything we ordered. The food was hot and perfectly seasoned. It was a lovely dinner with the family and we can’t wait to come back and try brunch for the grown ups. Thank you so much to our hostess for letting us seat a little on the later side d/t bad weather delaying travel. This place is gona be our new favorite place.

Great as always! Food was wonderful and so was the service!

One of the best Rusty Buckets locations. The staff is very professional and welcoming. We were there at 5:30 and our server reminded us to order before 6 to get the happy hour specials which were amazing. The food was delicious! I wish I would have gotten the server’s name because she was fantastic. Lovely smile, polite and gracious..she would be great in health care too!

We go to this location regularly, but on this particular visit the food was just ok. Food temperature was just so-so and the portion seemed smaller. We'll definitely go back again, but maybe not at prime dinner time. Perhaps just lunch. Thanks.

Food was great and our server Megan was great we had two tables for our son's graduation lunch everything was right and she was very attentive even with only two servers working