Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

4062 Gramercy St, Columbus - 43219
252 reviews
American Pubs Comfort Food
(614) 342-2063

We are visiting from MI. & Tx. & stopped for quick dinner. Our waiter was so wonderful food great & atmosphere nice.

Meal was great, service was good (keeping drinks filled). The waitress did not inform us that the flavored lemonade did not have free refills. Usually a restaurant makes you aware. Was charged for 9 lemonades, again at some point make the customer aware they spent $50 on non-alcoholic beverages. Waitress offered signature deep fried pickles for free, yet I was charged. As the food was really tasty, I would not return based on the service and charges I did not expect to pay.

I purchased the fish and chips with a strawberry lemonade. My meal was amazing and fresh. Being able to sit at a booth with an open patio was refreshing. Feeling the breeze and sipping on my authentic beverage was what I needed after a long day. The staff I encountered had great customer service. I felt seen as soon as I walked through the door. I will be back.

It was a wonderful experience. My husband and I have never ate here before and the experience was amazing. We are looking forward to our next visit.I ordered a turkey burger with fries and he had a NY Strip Steak. We had wonderful drinks and appetizers.Fried Pickles are a lil greasy, they are amazing. It caught me by surprise at how delicious a warm pickle could taste.We love our waitress Destiny. We are sooo looking forward to visiting again.

Pale ale. Burgers

Their food is consistently excellent. My wife and I usually stop here when we drive out to Easton. Their Bucket burger is really good, and the Mac and Cheese is incredible! The Ruben is really good too. Highly recommend this place.

Waiter was really nice and kind! Brussels are my favorite! Fish sandhwich was good but idk if there was a hair in it or not :( also that drink is so good !

Great, fun location. We were just there over the holiday. They were really busy and seated us quickly. The kids in our group sat at a bench and the adults (3 of us) sat at one of the high tables just by them. The food was really good! I had the chicken quesadilla, my son had a burger and my daughter had the club sandwich and all were hits. I recommend if you are looking for a down to earth, sport bar kind of vibe that wasn't overboard. Just right. With friendly staff and good food! Prices were reasonable too.

Stopped in before a movie to grab a late lunch. Food was great as always, but let me tell you about the waitress. Stephanie was AWESOME! Her charm, her personality.......WOW!! Stephanie, thanks for the conversation and making me feel like i'm more than just a customer!! You're amazing!!!!

My first time at The rusty bucket I was well pleased about the food! I was there for a birthday party so we will sit it all the way in the back and in private rooms and our waiter was well knowledge about the large menu! I was very surprised how knowledgeable he was when asking different questions. I develop new allergies so I have to make sure I wasn't killing myself eating food. This man must have studied hard because he knew everything. I had a nice Philly cheese steak it was very meaty with sauteed onions and peppers with no mushrooms. I had onion rings in the side my God the onion rings really took the show. Oh for my appetizer I had chicken tenders with fresh french fries. You should give him a try