Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

2116 Henderson Rd, Columbus - 43220
166 reviews
Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Shaved Ice
(614) 457-7290

Terrible staff. Rude, unfriendly and unwelcoming. Sketchy area. Not very safe even in board daylight. There was an attack on someone right in front of their window and they just watched and laughed. The attacker was screaming and yelling and pounding on cars and they just laughed. People think associating this area with upper Arlington makes it safe. It's NOT safe at all. I know I will never be back.

Great choice of frozen treatsCustard and gelato and Italian ice and concretes of many flavors mixed to your pleasure

First time ever being here!!! I got an cherry ice slushy and it was SOOOOOOO amazing!!! I have NEVER had a such good flavored ice before!!! I definitely recommend trying!!!! I know it’s just ice with flavor but like mannnn it’s amazing ice with flavor!!!and little cherry bites in it as well mmmm

My favorite go to spot in the city! I love taking my dog and grabbing a pup cup!

Great upgrade of the shop. Always a fun place to come!

I love Rita's a lot, had it for the first time in Philly where it's more popular there. The real fruit is what attracted me to want one

10/10 I love this place! A kind sir behind the counter even offered me a sample while I was waiting for my Mudslide

Tasted great! Wasn't as much as I would have liked, my concrete didn't full up the cup completely, but the overall custard experience was great!

Wasnt open when their multiple online listings said they were. Edit: they then commented under that they are closed for holiday. Which is fine thats understandable. But why do i have to find that out through a review? Why no holiday times postings?

Very yummy! I got the brownie sandwich. Gotta go back and try the mango ice.