No.1 Gyro Shoppe

3591 W Broad St, Columbus - 43228
162 reviews
Greek
(614) 272-6244

We regularly do larger (5-10) orders for my work and they always get our order correct. I call it ahead and it's fresh when I come to pick it up and pay. Employees are always polite and food is great! I also feel like it's a pretty good price!

Been coming here intermittently for over a decade. Great flavor and the prices have remained reasonable, especially in the face of inflation and compared to other quick service restaurants. Employees always seem nice and the location is relatively clean. Portion's generally seem fair, occasionally I'll get a smaller meat portion than previous times, etc. I can't speak to the authenticity of the cuisine culturally, but it is great tasting food and their gyros are better than anything I've had elsewhere (Loops, Arby's, Crazy Greek). A must-eat on the West Side.

Staff is very accommodating when it comes to modifications of menu items. The food is great, but the fries are out of the world. Recommendation: make a #11 meal of a burger with burger patty AND gyro meat. My boys love getting that from there. The staff has ALWAYS been very friendly

Tasty food prepared well, and quickly. Reasonably priced. Last night, I had feta cheese dip (served w pita) - very good, (Oh! The indulgent calories!) Really like the pita bread, toasted, soft, good mouth feel (chewy but not too chewy), always served quite warm. Gyro pitas are packed full of ingredients, yummy sauce. Usually great french fries: crisp outside. (sometimes I've bought when they were not cooked (fried to a golden brown) as i prefer.) Greek Steak salad: generous portion of flattened steak, traditional Greek ingredients, good size portion for the price ($10). Although often busy, they seem to move people through drive thru quickly. Tried lentil soup for the 1st time: is ok, not spicy. It's good for you! Spinach pie in flakey pastry - my favorite way to eat spinach! All types of baklava: all good! Very friendly service every time i go - which is a few times a year - but they make me feel like I'm a regular customer they are glad to see. Maybe i have a doppelganger?

Use to come here every so often, food was always good. Ordered the #10 hamburger there was no cheese on it, toppings were also not good, and the fries which are the best thing here were soggy. Won't be returning for a very long time. Will change review if I ever do go back and they go actually learn to cook their fries and put toppings on their food.

Always have a good experience when I come here. They are very nice people. My mom and I ended up ordering the wrong thing and didn't realize it until we looked in our bag, the guy at the window offered to replace what we messed, but we didn't want to hassle the fella. Our mess up was actually really good

Always quality. Had the grilles chicken on rice plate,it was perfect. The sauce is delicious. Friendly service always too.

Always a good meal. Prices have risen of late but what hasn't. I love the gyro salad and usually take a little extra gyro meat and stick it on the Pita for a kid.

Maybe I didn't go at the right time, but portion size was small for the price, and it just wasn't the #1 Gyro that I was hoping for. The Baklava didn't seem fresh. The spinach pie was burned, so, unfortunately I had to spit out the first bite (the corner). Friendly drive thru. However, I asked for a receipt, and she seemed confused, had to ask for help and the "helper" couldn't produce a receipt for me either.

customer service is amazing here. everyone is polite and attentive