Showed up at 8pm on a Saturday. We wanted to get in and out and only ordered pizzas by the slice that was available when we ordered. There were a couple of people ahead of us but overall it wasn't busy. It took 35 minutes for our food to come out. Staff kept pulling pies from the oven and stacking them on racks for later. Perhaps they were understaffed? The food was good but the service was slow. If you go, lower your expectations.
Things I do: Eat pizza.Things I don’t do: Leave bad reviews.Normally I’d just keep my mouth shut and move on but this was absurd. I come from the land of New York City where pizza and convenience is plentiful, so maybe my opinion here is skewed. In NY, pizza is cheap and easily accessible. At Mikey’s late night, pizza is expensive and difficult. Somehow they have applied every barrier possibly to achieving a drunken slice of cheese. It started with the security guard not letting me in to a nearly empty establishment, only to abandon her post so that she could eat, then it was a free-for-all. After that I embarked on a long slow journey to the front of the line to acquire a slice of cheese. Another arduous process. I will not be revisiting this establishment. I’d rather wait for my oven to preheat so that I can enjoy a delicious Red Baron personal pizza. As you can tell I have low standards and the late night slice failed to meet those expectations. I suggest their management team take a deep dive in to the movie “the founder” so that they can improve workflows and expedite their product. Or dont. I don’t care. I would like to clarify that their staff was friendly and was working diligently to satisfy all of the customers.
Cool vibes. Great pizza. Unicorn sauce is massively overrated, but that's okay. Sodas here are a little bit of a hidden gem. Staff is very cool except for the "Security" guy that's just over 5ft tall, just barely old enough to drive, but still has the audacity to call women he doesn't know "sweetheart" in a most condescending way. Misogyny isn't cool.
I have never left a bad review in all my 40 years, but there were zero fountain drinks available, and the cashier kept allowing customers to order drinks even though she was aware. -No "out of order" sign, no refund nor solution offered. Horrible customer service.*I wanted to update that the owner reached out quickly and worked to fix the issue!
Awesome pizza! We ordered take out and pizza was warm and on time!
Came to Columbus for a meeting, drove 2 hours in the snow only to find the meeting was canceled ?So, hungry and stuck til morning and it was midnight...so I Googled Food Near Me and it was around the corner. I order The Balboa Philly Cheese Steak PizzaAnd it was delicious!!!! They heated it up so the pizza was hot and the crust was crunchy.If ever in Columbus and you want some Pizza, stop by Mikey's Late Night Slice. You won't be disappointed
Pretty damn good pizza! Great atmosphere with museum-level artwork! Service is friendly. Prices are difficult ($27 for a pie and $5 a slice - yikes!) But worth it when you haven't had real pizza in a while
The best vegan pizza I've ever had. I had the buffalo chicken vegan slice and it was everything! Seasoning was perfect.
A nice little pizza joint with a cool vibe. It's a good place to get a quick slice, and they have a huge range of options for whole pies. I like their dipping sauces too. The drink selection isn't great, though.
Absolutely love this place. Had two slices spicy, two pepperoni, and two cheese. Plenty of unicorn sauce and a little garlic sauce. These slices are worth the two hour drive. We are going to come here every time!