Forgot to take a picture because we were hungry and everything was so delicious!We went earlier this week and were greeted by the owner/chef who was incredibly friendly and welcoming. He made us feel comfortable and answered every question we had about the food (the chicken wings were top notch, cooked and spiced perfectly- didn't even need the sauce on the side). I always love a good NY style pizza and the pizza we got with extra cheese, mushrooms, and pepperoni was exceptional. The sauce, made in-house, was superb and the overall experience was very warm.The restaurant was clean, comfortable, and the personal engagement was a welcome touch. I look forward to going back and trying so many other dishes on the menu.
We were welcomed so nicely, whole staff is sweet, funny and helpful. Pizza is amazing, we got the 20in and my husband was in heaven. The crust is buttery, pieces are huge and the toppings are fresh. The owner Roz is so sweet, checked in on us many times and introduced himself and had a nice chat. It is a very welcoming and yummy experience.
My experience started a little rocky, about an hour before their closing time, with poor service on the phone (put on hold and never came back). Because of their high rating, however, I decided to drive to the store and place my order and I am so glad I did. The pizza was amazing and BIG (be careful if you order a large, it's 20 inches). The staff was friendly and worked past closing time to make my order happen.
The owner, staff, and food are fantastic—a must-try—a true hidden gem. The owner makes everything from scratch.
We got calzones. There were awesome. I had meatballs and I haven't had meatballs that good since my mother died. Authentic Italian taste. JR had Italian sausage in his. They were big enough a family. Owner is very friendly and nice. I would highly recommend this place.
Pizza is still good but it was unevenly cooked. They were obviously having issues as we got there at 4:30 on a Friday and it took 1.25 hours to get our food, one medium pizza. Only one other group eating in waiting on food. The pick up orders were also all waiting extra for their food. When we finally got our order it was the wrong size pizza. Barely got a sorry. I understand being understaffed but be more apologetic with you customers. We love the pizza but it will be a long time before we go back. If the pizza wasn't good we would definitely never go back.
This is the BEST pizza joint in Columbus, no exaggeration. The service here is great, everyone is super nice. All the food is made right in front of you, and is hand-spun. Everything is homemade, and the dessert is also fresh. I definitely would recommend bringing your family here, as portions are quite large, but that isn’t a problem what so ever.
The food was very good. The service was slow but I didn’t really mind. Everyone was so friendly and when you see the kitchen moving you’ll cut them some slack. Food that good is well worth the wait. People from the east coast, this taste like home!
Borgata’s has THE best sausage stuffed cubanelle peppers in the city! Served with a spicy marinara and melted cheese. Mmmmm… The crusty Italian bread makes this a delightful meal or appetizer to share. The homemade pastas are huge and pizzas are so good, too. Try them out!
First and foremost, the food is always awesome. 5 star food.2 stars because they won't serve you without a mask. Vaxxed? Doesn't matter.If you love good food, go here, but I won't be giving them business until their mask policy gets lifted. 2 weeks to stop the spread, 2 years later. Done with supporting businesses that continue to uphold this nonesense.