I moved to an apartment nearby around 3 years ago. I got their pamphlet menu, and had an exploratory whim, so I tried them out.I don't know what it is. The pizza is so thin and yet so chewy. It's the perfect mix of buttery, greasy and sweet that just hits all the right notes for me. I get a large and end up eating 3/4 of it, it just goes down so easy. I love the taste they put in their dough, it's just a darn shame that it's impossible to not overeat so it doesn't last longer.The sandwiches here are delicious as well, they use their own baked bread and I can tell you it's damn good stuff.I think I had the pasta once and it didn't knock my socks off, but I will say I had no problems eating it either. Great spot, friendly staff. I hope these guys do well in the years to come.
Great food, friendly staff, and quick service. No frills dine-in experience, but anything you need or want they will get. It's about the food. While we were there it was impressive to see how quickly the food was made and out the door for delivery. The baked penne with marinara sauce was a hit with us. The meat lovers pizza and garlic knots are great as well.
Calzones and cannoli are SO good - not to mention big enough to share (or get two meals out of)
Thank you for making it so like pizza again. The cheese garlic bread was the best my mushroom and sausage was sooo great.
Food quality is consistently excellent, Staff is great. Chicken pasta Alfredo is awesome and ANY calzone is huge !!!
I ordered a pepperoni pizza and one of the ‘Tony’s Calzone’ this evening for New Years. I hadn’t ordered from Big Tony’s before and “impressed” would be an understatement. The staff was great; very kind and gave an accurate estimate on the time needed for the order. The calzone was top notch as was the pizza. I worked at a pizza place years ago and I have to say: these guys know what they’re doing. Topping proportions were right, the dough was evenly cooked and whoever stretched it did a fantastic job. A perfect sphere. The pizza sauce is amazing as well. ZERO complaints here. One very happy customer and a long term customer well earned!
I love these people! Small business with friendly owners, fairly priced, great quality, good consistency (your regular order will taste the same each time). My only complaint is a personal preference; I like the crust a little crispy on the bottom. But my gripe is not worth knocking off a star because that's a me problem.
I tried this place twice….gave them two chances and both times I was disappointed with the pie. It’s sooo mediocre I should of went to Kroger’s and got a frozen pizza ?. Dams club Pizza has this pepperoni and sausage beat. The sauce barely there and the sausage taste like air bites. That’s right air bites. Ever tasted air? That’s what their sausage tastes like…. The cheese was gross in texture.Don’t waste your money! The 4.5 stars had to be friends of the business. Total bs!
Was skeptical to order pizza im NY through and through but, the taste was good it was the sauce and crust for me. Wings were meaty and flavorful and it made it here just in time for game. Next time my job sends me out here or when i visit columbus i will order again.
This is my go to spot now! Excellent pizza and you can even get it delivered(how novel) without dealing with Grubhub.