Pizza was good, but the bar upstairs is what sealed the deal. The lovely ladies upstairs had great personalities and made great drinks. Ask about the peanut butter tequila. Or ask for a PB & J.
I went with my 2 kids and we ordered lunch specials. The slice of pizza was bigger than my kids lol. It was well worth the price plus you get a side and a drink. The food was good, the atmosphere was nice, the establishment was clean and the staff was amazing. My kids loved it as well. I will be returning.
Goodfellas is great. Especially during a night out but if you do go to goodfellas, best time to go is during the lunch special. You get a slice of pizza with a drink and a breadstick! Such a great and delicious deal.
We ordered a Chicken, Bacon Ranch pizza and loved it! You can also buy pizza by the slice. Upstairs is a bar with great drinks for pretty good prices. I love the theme and its always clean. There is also a patio to sit outside and tvs to watch sports. Great place!
Great pizza at a fantastic price!!! (I pleasantly shocked at the bill for three of us to eat)! We ate upstairs, outside on the patio and it was a really nice experience. Not much parking right next to the place, but there's a huge parking lot about 50 yards away (free parking), and the walk is flat, and takes about 5 minutes or less.
First time trying Goodfellas and I like it. You can order by the slice here. I enjoyed a slice of cheese and slice of green olive mushroom. Generous size slices. I will be back to try more. The tables have shakers of Italian seasoning, Parmesan cheese and crushed red peppers. There is a second floor bar here.
I like this place, the food is good and the beer selection is great. The restaurant is cold and the tables are way to small for ordering the sort of food that they serve. We literally had to use a chair for holding most of the things that belong on the table because the tables are to small for the pizza they serve. The service could have been more attentive. Our server got caught up with other customers chit chatting for far too long, but was otherwise good.I try to be honest and true with my reviews, and I think that I am doing so here. it is a good place with good food, but some of the details are missing. Get bigger tables, heat the place up, and get your servers to focus and you guys can hit it out of the park. I am very happy to change my review as needed.
The guys on the phone when you order act mean, but don’t let them scare you. This location looks like their OTR location, but it is much smaller, with an uncomfortable small dining room. There is an upstairs here, but I don’t know what the hell is up there. Some girl in front of me in line had a super annoying laugh and she went up there. I thought to myself “good”, because the annoyance was gone. This is the only reason that I did not check it out.It was busy tonight, Thursday night around 9:30 PM. There were 5 randoms in line ordering piZza by the slice, while I waited in line for my carry-out. This surprised me, relatively late on a weeknight.All the people working behind the counter will totally ignore you, so don’t take it personally. You know what though? It’s worth it.The cashier guy was hustling, but he was very kind, given the circumstances.This is a great New York style hand tossed pizza and it costs much less than it should.I made the mistake of ordering a large tonight for my son and I. I picked it up because they do not deliver, but I could barely fit it in my car. You think that I’m joking.It is great pizza too - great pizza - I think maybe better than Dewey’s or even Taglio.Check out the pic of my pizza - I am writing this review to tell you about the quality - not the quantity.
Been here two times for carryout, both times I checked in at the time I was quoted and told my pizzas had not even been started because "things are busy." I just want correct time estimates, this is ridiculous. The pizza is good, but I guess carryout orders are pushed to the back of the line, or the management is poor. I'd like to be gracious in a pandemic but I can't keep wasting my time and won't be back.
Great tasting, fresh pizza. They had an 8.00 lunch special which was very a generous portion. Fun to watch them making the crust:) Very friendly guys working there! Highly recommend?