This was my first visit to Goodfellas and it was awesome. There server was friendly and very helpful. The lunch special was extremely affordable.And the pizza was awesome! Great visit here, will be back when I'm back in town.
I will say from someone who's had some great pizza all around the world Goodfellas is by far one of the best. The staff is very hospitable and engaging and the food.... well let's just say good coma incoming. The speakeasy upstairs has a great variety of drinks, but I will say the wooden Nickel is my favorite. I could and have drank those all night. If you're ever in an area with Goodfellas they are a MUST to go visit.
Goodfellas is the best pizza in Cincinnati to my personal opinion, no matter if eat it at 12pm or 1am, it's always great, happy to know that all the branches around Cincinnati are great!
Pizza is good. Had it a few times. Could use more toppings at times and when busy the pizza can get just a bit underdone. But overall a good pie. Breadsticks are hilariously massive!!
When hype meets reality you get a restaurant like this. We tried some pizza and an order of buffalo chicken breadsticks. Both exceeded expectations. The pizza is a relatively thin, but doughy, New York slice with a crispy bottom. Staff was kind and was working hard. 10/10.
The vibe, workers and food at this location are amazing! We stopped in this time to grab some breadsticks while we waited for our table at another restaurant. Ended up getting two kinds of bread and a slice. ??♂️ Delicious! ?
Giant slices, fresh salads, tasty food all around. A really cool vibe and generous servings for the prices. There's a few good fellas in the greater Cincinnati area and they're all worth visiting
I love this place. I will admit, I have never bought an entire pizza from them, but I frequently drop in for a single slice and a breadstick. If I'm being completely honest, I drop in for a breadstick and a cheese sauce maybe too often! If you go, the cheese sauce is a MUST. Their ranch isn't my favorite, but the garlic is top notch. They have a lunch special that is a killer price.
The staff here was really nice and personable! We came in right before the crowd got there. They were very friendly. We ordered a whole pizza and it took about 20 minutes to make give or take a bit. It was basic, half cheese, and half pepperoni. The crust was soft and melted in your mouth. The signature for me was whatever they made their sauce with really stood out from other pizza joints I've been to. There's a huge bar upstairs I'd recommend as well. But the pizza and friendly staff are my reasons for wanting to come back!
Great pizza! Good customer service. Great atmosphere. Surprisingly long breadsticks. The workers were so friendly. We loved talking to them. Would recommend: