Jerry's Pizza

319 S Paint St #3829, Chillicothe - 45601
145 reviews
Pizza
(740) 773-1200

Loved the pizza! Only reason I have it 4/5 is the building looks kind of dumpy. My husband was not impressed that I picked this place to eat. Staff was very kind and good was great!

Went there to get a quick bite as I was waiting for car being worked on. It was anything BUT quick!! All I ordered was a small salad and some breadsicks! The salad took forever and the breadsticks did NOT come out with salad and of course they were burnt and awful. I came home and fed that to the birds, which I wasn't even sure about. They were not busy so that "excuse " will not fly. There was maybe 2 tables, and 1 at the bar, and maybe 2 to go orders while I waited and waited. The salad was fine when it finally came out, but I definitely would not go there if you are on ANY kind of a schedule at all! Also, do NOT order the cheesy breadsticks! I could not tell if they were cheesy or not because they were so burnt!

I really enjoyed my pizza and wings! Walked here while waiting on my truck to get loaded at the Mill. The Bartender is an amazing guy with a wonderful soul! May God bless you for being such a kind human being!!!

Soggy and sauce and cheese tasted different. So, disappointed! Have always looked forward to eating here since I was a little girl.

Absolutely amazing, the wings had that perfect crunch to it and perfectly seasoned and the pizza!? Oh God don't get me started. It also has a very good crunch to it, perfect amount of spice, perfect cheese. Absolutely will order again.

They have always been a great friendly place .An best pizza ever.

Great subs. Good pizza. Not always consistent. Not someplace to go for a quiet meal, or take a date to impress them. But I will be back for a sandwich or two..... oh and some decent drinks while you wait.

I was told this place was once awesome but today it just doesn’t live up to the hype. A somewhat dingy, old fashion/classic decor, that’s clean in some areas but also dirty in others. The service can be friendly but otherwise passive and others who are seemingly annoyed. The pizza is fair, with little cheese and consisting mostly of the veggie/meat toppings (Jerry’s Deluxe), sauce, and a decent crust, that is likely catering to a select taste (nostalgia?). The nachos were nothing special, akin to a convenience store special with the typical slow heated, glow yellow cheese with stale chips. Not absolutely terrible but somewhere for friends and could use a refresh all the way around from the food to the interior. May & Dec 2021

they like working are employees over 40 hours and not paying them overtime

I called ahead for pickup.The sweet pig pizza, zucchini fries, and Mac & Cheese bites were all super good!Great service and friendly staff.