Very tasty traditional Italian food. When I say huge portions, I mean huge. Do not underestimate it. We probably will share a single entrée next time, as we took more than half home of each, not realizing the portions were so huge and we got an appetizer. The stuffed pepper was super delicious. I don't like the weird set-up they have of ordering at the cashier by the door (which isn't continually staffed since) then sitting down and self-service soda.
My 12 year old found this place. She loves pizza and thought she wanted to try this place when we past it to go to Barnes and Noble. Anyways, glad she did! I love meat pizzas and the carnivore is my favorite. We’ve gone back 3 times now. My first time I thought the price was high, until I saw the size of the slice. I think you get even MORE when you order the full pizza (instead of by the slice) but either way the slices are massive.My wife picked up the pizza ? this time and she said she told the older Gentleman how much we loved the pizza and he was happy!! So I decided to leave this review as well. 100% recommend
My wife and I really enjoyed our dinner. I would say this is a hidden gem, but with the amount of business they were doing a lot of the public is quite aware of this restaurant. The first thing that hits you when you walk in is the wonderful angel of garlic sautéing. Shouldn't expect anything less from an Italian restaurant. The next thing is the friendliness of everyone working. The food is so good! It's all prepared to order. So you might feel like it's taking too long, but it's a good thing. The pizza was fantastic. PaPa GeGe hand tosses and baked it to perfection! We will definitely return to try a different pasta dish with a different sauce.
What a great find! Busy? Yes. A little pricey? Maybe. Great food? No doubt! Best pizza I have had in a long time and we eat a lot of pizza. NY style with multiple toppjngs was thin and yet still crispy. The outside crust was light fluffy and crispy. Staff was friendly and helpful and patient with us as 'newbies'. Regulars were just as friendly. Can't wait to try the rest of the menu at our new favorite italian restaurant!
Our meal was amazing! Service fast and friendly. They never disappoint.
Love there pizza. their prices are a little high but I highly recommend. Everything I ever got at this place was amazing. I'd give it 4.5 stars if it would let me.
One of the best pizza shops in Youngstown. Quality ingredients! handmade pizzas!
Awesome food! Great service! Papa GeGe's Italian Villa has the best pizza in the Mahoning Valley! The White Supreme Pizza is delicious!
Everytime I have been to PaPa GeGe's their food has been amazing! Goodbye Olive Garden . This is now our favorite Italian restaurant.
We will be back. The food was excellent. The people were friendly.