We love the pizza at Beavercreek Pizza Dive. The dough and pretzel bites with cheese and marinara sauce are awesome too. We loved trying new combinations during the Wednesday night buffet. You can’t beat unlimited pizza, pizza bites and a drink for $10 per person. The new owners have really transformed the business and adding the Wednesday night buffet is sure to be a big hit.
This was our first time ordering. My husband and I have been trying different places in the area. I was surprised by the $36 minimum for delivery but that's been addressed in someone else's review. Delivery took about 90 minutes, which was fine, its a Friday. I've worked at a number of pizza places throughout the years and I've never seen cheese do this. Not the sliding of toppings, but the complete change of texture. It turned into a Velveeta like substance that we just couldn't get past. I'm not sure if the sauce was too thin or what but it was weird and just got worse as the pizza cooled. As for the sliding, I called the store right away and was assured that they will make it right. The outstanding customer service is the main reason for 4 stars. Based on pizza alone, it would've been closer to 2.5, definitely not worth the money we paid.
I would have made this a 5 star rating after my first visit but they have shown the inability to maintain consistency. First time got two large pizzas and a Mediterranean salad which were fantastic. Second time get the same order and end up with a salad with what looked and tasted like days old left out lettuce wilted and soggy. The pizzas were extremely chewy and the cheese tasted like it had been burnt and then put on the pizza along with having the texture of eating a sponge. Even my kids pointed out the drastic difference. Could be a great restaurant if they could produce quality pizza and salads each time. Was really looking forward to having a new go to pizza joint.
I ordered my pizzas at 4:30pm so it would be ready when I got off work at 5:30. Watched them search for my order. The manager told the boy he should have put it in not wait for my pick up time. Another girl came out at the same time and said they had tons of orders to come back in 20 mins. So here I still sit. Waiting for my order. (Just heard from the back a girl says this was supposed to be done at 5:30? Why yes. It is now 6:15) lost my business and I am a first time customer. Did give me a free pizza for next order. But I don’t think I will be back. By the way people are very nice
This is my 2nd time eating pizza from here and the 1st with the new owners and I can't really tell the difference. The pizza is freaking awesome!!!!!!It's New York style an is really good! The Pepperoni and cheese was the best out of the 3 we ordered. The others BBQ chicken and meat deluxe were just fine as well.The service was very fast and friendly. Pizza came out hot and cheesy.The ac must have been off or something because it was HOT inside.I will return
Hands down the best pizza I have had, and I love pizza. I had it at a Cornhole tournament at the VFW, it was provided as food for the event, usually a recipe for super mediocre pizza (but free!). Not in this case! BEST PIZZA EVER! Crust is the perfect thickness, and is balanced with a perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni (I haven't had any other topping combinations but believe me, I will very soon). If you are looking for classic pizzeria style pizza, hands down this is the best I have ever had, can't believe this place is in my own backyard. Big thanks to the event organizers too for getting it from here.
While I just chose to recommend beavercreek pizza dive, that is based on past orders only. I do not want to base a referral solely on one order. Past orders have always been goid. Tonight I called to order an extra large supreme pizza to pick up. When the young man gave me my total, I thought I heard wrong so I repeated the price of $33 for an extra large pizza? I was almost speechless! The menu I have said it was $22.99. Even if the menu was a little old that is a huge price increase. I have always liked your food and service and liked supporting a local business. I'm afraid I can no longer do that. It saddens me to say this. I may check back for daily specials but sometimes the special is just not what I'm looking for.
Worst take out experience of my life. Won't let you inside. Only place I know of that is still doing curb side only, acting like we are still under lock down. I called and my wait time was 15 to 20 minutes. I got a text message to verify when I arrived. When I arrived I replied to the text message and verified that it was received 12 minutes after I ordered the pizza. I waited 26 minutes until another customer who arrived 5 minutes before me got their food handed to them. I received no call back. I was completely ghosted. Wooooooooooow!!!!!!
Used to be out favorite pizza place by far. Loved supporting a small local business. Not so much anymore. The pizza seems to have gone down in quality. It's often almost raw in the center, and I end up being out more when it gets here Also raising the minimum for delivery to $36 (!) is just kinda ridiculous and the last straw. For 2 of us that is an absurd amount of food. They just really seem to not WANT to deliver and are trying to discourage people from getting pizza delivered. Noted. We won't be ordering anymore.
Our pizza was hot and perfectly made. They have great pizza, but it is a little pricey for what you get. We'll definitely be going back, but it won't become our go-to place because of the price.