An Athens tradition. As amazing now as it was ten years ago. Both locations are mouth-watering, always fresh, and super cheap.
The pizza is GREAT it's a deep dish but the sizes they have are half sheet or full sheet or you can buy by individual slice idk if buying the half sheet or full comes half cheese and half pepperoni even though I said for entire pizza I got the half sheet which is 8 slicesBut its really really EXPENSIVE but for trying it for my first time I wasn't disappointed
It’s pretty alright pizza. A little pricey considering it’s overall quality (it’s not bad, but not amazing). But as the only “late night pizza joint” in Athens, there’s little to complain about.
GoodFella’s Pizza is an Athens staple for a reason, and easily the best fourthmeal after an evening of Court Street debauchery.The prices are just right for the amount of pizza you get; the slices are huge. There isn’t usually a wait, and the staff are super friendly. They also deliver through DoorDash, which is a huge plus.Ignore the other oddly negative reviews. This place is amazing. You won’t be disappointed.
Rude. Will not take your order over the phone, they answer the phone but tell you to go through doordash which doubles the price, stupid
If you like really hot thicker crust pizza this is a great place to try!
Great pizza, team there are awesome! Stopped in and got the last pizza of the day to take back to Logan with us
Pretty sad when you gotta cook your own pizza that you paid $30 for from good fellas pizza! If someone can tag them please do! It won't let me post to the page
The pizza used to be better a few years ago, also I’m mad they upped their prices which are already kinda high to begin with.
The pizza sucks, the staff are rude