NY Pizza it is Not ! Card board with a ok sauce.Ordered mild wings which would make you think they would have some flavor,they were PLAIN over cooked wings with a side of buffalo sauce.Meatballs and garlic knots just ok
Tonight we ordered 2 19 inch pizzas. One xtra cheese and one pepperoni. When we got home we realized there was a mistake and both were cheese. They told us to come back they wld put pepperoni on it and slap it bk in the oven..WTH ??? I admit we shld have ckd b4 lving but omg really ? I am very disappointed to say the least. This place has changed and gone down hill for a bit now and tonight done it for me.
Tony's is one of very very few places that I consider the real deal pizzeria in the area! Growing up in New Jersey, then to move here was quite a culture shock to say the least.... but Tony's 1000% makes food just like "Home"!Giant pizza pies, and slices just like you found at the boardwalk and anything I've ever had from here is absolutely amazing! They are usually always busy (any time I've ever gone to eat) but that's because they are so freaking good!
I have never had NY style pizza. I knew it was thin but that's all. My husband ordered an everything large pizza. So disappointed !! It really was tasteless with a thin very soggy crust that was hard to eat because it was so tough!Now we are afraid to ever try NY style. There were hardly any meat or veggies on it. Very sparse. Not for the price. We ended up throwing a bunch of it away.
Tried the pizza here while visiting from NY. We got a huge pie with pepperoni. I was pleasantly surprised. Place seemed busy and I suspect it's pretty good for the area. Definitely worth trying if your in the area.
As far as pizza goes they are great but the customer service and whoever they have taken the orders is downright terrible. I called the place in order tonight and the kid said can I have your name, so I gave it to him he says no I need another name we already have one of those....I thought he was joking. I said well how about you use my 1st name and last name initial because I'm the 1 picking up so why would I give you a different name. He said uhhh...I guess then hung up. I called back again and told him I would like to place an order using my 1st and last name and he said well I already have one of your 1st name so what do you want me to do. Told him he was extremely unprofessional and hung up because I'm not sure why that is so difficult.A review to this pizzeria would be to train your employees how to professionally handle phone calls because 1st impressions are everything.
Sorry Tony's ordered a pizza last Saturday. The worst Tony's pizza ever. Not sure what happened to your quality control. I had worked all day and just wanted to go home and enjoy a treat for dinner. I threw most of it in the garbage. Really not good. Crust was aweful!!
To all my fans out thereThat has read my reviews.Let me tell you aboutTony'sPizza. This place brings back so many great memories of time when I was young in New Jersey in a town called Seaside Heights yes the Jersey Shore. Not the show represents I am the real Jersey shore man, and Tony Pizza brought back so many great memories I had their. There is a place called the Saw Mill in Seaside Heights it was a small bar with a kitchen in the middle. There were always live music. The pizza was amazing back then you got a huge slice and a drink for five dollars. Well when I asked for two slices of pepperoni I didn't open the box till I got to work and I was like OMFG. Then the taste was and the size brought me back to the SAW MILL. THIS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA . A slice or pie your gonna g we t it from Tony.
I placed an order for pick up last night. When I arrived I realized I hadn’t considered how I would get my food to the car and carry my son. When my order was brought out, without hesitation, the young man behind the counter offered to bring the food out to my car. It may have been a small gesture but I haven’t stopped bragging about my experience at Tony’s. The food was delicious! We will definitely be returning.
Make sure your buyers know what is acceptable for payment. If it's cash only, state that on the phone. Instead of acting like you're in high-school and treat the customer like garbage because he didn't have cash. Yes, everyone in the store saw how you treated your customer. That makes a few customers lost today. Absolutely unprofessional and childish. Enjoy the pizzas you made and didn't sell.