Papa's Subs & Pizza Holly Springs

511 N Main St, Holly Springs - 27540
146 reviews
Pizza Mediterranean
(919) 557-1919

We loved the ham and pineapple pizza also the hamburger and tomato pizza we got they were outstanding. The staff was great they were very helpful . We go there a lot and the food is always very tasty especially the pizza . My friends like it , and they always ask about the pizza and give it lots of compliments.

Consistently great food for years now and the best Philly and chicken cheesesteak subs period.We did have one order that was not right and I was ok with it really but they insisted on making it 100% correct and gave us dessert on the house and that’s one incorrect order of many many orders over 5-6 years now that’s consistent and in these days that’s top notch superior service.Great people and great food.

Clean place, cheerful atmosphere, friendly speed, delicious multi-kind pizza at cheap prices

Good food, delicious atmosphere, employees are kind and the value is here! Alot of food for your money. I'll be coming back!

Very nice guys very nice food

I have seen some poor reviews, but it is clear the place is under new management. I have had Pizza etc and Donna Kebab from here and it has been perfect. The only word of caution would be they have some young staff taking orders, so I recommend you are clear with what you want of ordering by phone and have them clearly repeat it back to you. I have no problem recommending.

Underrated pizza. Having tried all of Holly Springs I can say this is the best “NY” pizza I have eaten. At a fair price too. Acme pizza is overhyped and the “go to” for most residents here, but trust me, this is better.

Always great pizza, the owner is hands on.

Eh... honestly kinda disappointed. Kinda burnt, kinda expensive for what I got, better cold. Sorry guys, high hopes and they weren't met.

Liked the Dark Blue T-shirt uniforms, very cool. The employees are cordial, courteous, which I appreciate. My only issue is their sandwiches are covered in a lot of cheese, it Masks a lot of the flavors of the other ingredients in the sandwich themselves. And the meatballs in a meal or sandwich pack flavor/seasoning. But I do like coming here.