Reynolds Sandwich Shop

1437 2nd Ave NW, Hickory - 28601
120 reviews
Southern Burgers
(828) 327-9452

Forgot all about this jewel of a food joint. Got the BBQ sandwich onion rings and tea. Decently priced when everyone else is jacking prices. The BBQ was outstanding. I definitely will go back to this hidden gem

Best family owned diner!!! Doesnt matter what u get its good... ESP their chicken tenders...

Always wonderful I have eat here since I was a little girl and I am a 40 ur old women now!!!!!! You can't get a better burger in Hickory than Reynolds

The bad. The burger was dry.The good. The blt absolutely amazing. Hopefully the burger was just an off day.

Best burger and fries in Hickory / Granite Falls! Right off I-40 and US 321. Behind the McDonalds and Baskin Robin's. Great value, easy access, quick service, large menu, and favorite of the locals. Order, pickup, and pay at the window. Take it home or eat in the car! And...Pepsi-Cola!

I was nervous because I saw a lot of cars and I had a limited lunch break but to my surprise the service was super fast. The man taking my order was very friendly. The juicy burger was topped with lettuce, tomatoes, sweet slaw, and tangy chili. Crinkle fries were crispy and delicious. Nevermind going to McDonald's which is two buildings down and come to this place. So good.

They have awesome barbecue and it's also a great place to eat breakfast large homemade sandwiches.

Everything that you eat here is delicious , buffet here is wonderful no waiting time , very nice waitress., and very affordable , an enjoyable place to relax and enjoy the moment !!!!!

Great Chicken Fillet Sandwich with Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo for lunch today. This was the first time I've been back to Reynolds in about 15 years. After being almost a daily regular for several years, when I worked in Hickory, I wanted to stop and see if it was still just as good as before. The Giant Burgers still appeared giant. Fries were great. I remember the fried chicken being the best chicken around the area. That's what I had in mind today was 2 fried chicken legs, potato wedges and their awesome Sweat Tea. Sadly, they no longer fry chicken on the bone and can't get potato wedges, so they're discontinued until further notice?. The Sweat Tea was, however, spot on! I hear the tenders are really good, but the price scared me at 4 for $7.40. All in all, great experience, but not excellent. I was able to get 1 of the 3 things I was craving. Today, my rating stands at 4 out of 5 ⭐s. Bring back the hand battered ? fried chicken ? and potato wedges and I'll gladly give 5 ⭐s.

I love this place! Everything is good but my favorite is their grilled pimento cheese and banana pudding. They have great Cheeseburgers and hot dogs as well. When I want a really good hot dog all the way this is where I go. It's easy to get in and out plus they are fast.