Have had good meals here before, but got take out tonight. No taste pizza, I mean flat. The Garlic knots I assume we're made yesterday. Hockey pucks. You know their like that when you put them in the take out box.. why. Will try again though due to many good meals before.
DON’T ORDER PIZZA HERE! This is the last time I order pizza from Anthony’s! I don’t mind paying more for a quality pizza but now they are just ripping people off. Ordered a large white pizza with bacon it was $23.65, what I got was a very super almost cracker thin crust with next to no toppings including next to no cheese.
I made my first purchase at Anthony’s a few weeks ago and ordered a medium cheese and a medium veggie pizza. I got home and opened the box of cheese and it was BURNT, opened my veggie and it was cooked to perfection. I couldn’t seem to figure out where they went wrong. My pizza was hard, not edible for my small children so I went back and they made me another one. Problem solved. Except I went back more recently and noticed there was a sign on the front counter that said their pizza is cooked so it’s golden and if you like it “undercooked” then that should be requested. I found it to be distasteful. If you have more than one customer complaining about burnt pizza, maybe you should look within for any faults.Especially, when I opened my box of cheese and it didn’t look like this. And guess what? I didn’t have to request it to be undercooked.The pizza is delicious by the way.
They hands down have the best NY style pizza in Clayton. Wings were good and decent size, but were sitting in way too much sauce.
I’m from NJ and have tried a number of different pizza joints in the area since I’ve been down here. Some ok others not so much. If you are a NJ/NYC native check it out. This has been the ONLY place that reminds me of pizza from home.
Absolutely incredible food!
Fantastic lasagna! The fried ravioli were very good!
Was very good. Was us, the kids and the grandparents and we all enjoyed our food.
Excellent food, excellent service and very reasonable prices considering the high quality. The bolognese was excellent and clearly made from scratch to include fresh tomatoes. The alfredo was one of the best either of us have had. The owner/manager was running food and looked at the plates coming out as if he loved them.If anyone has a complaint they should go stuff their face with unlimited salad and breadsticks at Olive Garden.
If you want real quality NY Style pizza and 5 star restaurant service, then you need to check out Anthony's Pizza and Pasta. You're doing your stomach a disservice if you don't.Seriously, stop reading this review and go order.