Katie's Cottage

521 Central Park Ave, Yonkers - 10704
141 reviews
Irish Salad
(914) 965-0422

Excellent I enjoyed for a quick and fast bitI go back

I always loved it here always came for the trivia nights but I came today on a Sunday afternoon and was not happy. I understand things happen and kitchen gets backed up but what they should’ve done was told us when we walked in “hey there is going to be a long wait,” but instead we ended up waiting 2 hours for our food. When it finally did come out they told me they had run out of what I had asked for (which was the main reason I ordered the meal to begin with) so they gave me something else instead. What??! Again, I understand things happen and if I didn’t just wait 2 hours I would’ve been ok with that but they had plenty of time to come out and let me know beforehand because I would have changed my order. After the combination of waiting 2 hours and then telling me when they bought out the food finally they didn’t have what I asked for the least they could’ve done was at least offer a discount but nothing. To top it off, my poor father who’s in his 70s was getting very uncomfortable sitting there for so long, just a very overall miserable experience. It’s a shame because I really liked it there before today. So disappointed I expected so much better from them. I’ll never go back.

Just went for my 1st time & was so disappointed, should be Lucky for a Party of 3 to go & want to spent $200, THEY'RE FRONT DOOR WAS LOCKED..

Staff was very nice, however it took a while for us to get our food. A Caucasian family that came in after got their food faster which seemed very odd. We are both paying American money so not sure what happened there but whatever. The waitresses were gems but I think the cook might need some help. The steak was ordered medium well and came out well done. My bacon was so crispy it literally fell apart on my hands. Decent place but probably won’t be returning.

Terrific food and great, friendly, attentive service. The corned beef on rye might be the best in the State. The Jamison's Wings are zesty and delightful, a meal of themselves. The brown bread is fantastic. it's like a second home.

Delicious food and, in my humble opinion, the best Guinness in Yonkers by a country mile. Beautiful bar with great ambiance and the service is top notch. One of my favorites, keep it up!

So happy I found this neighborhood gem! Quaint, cozy and excellent food and prices! Will be a regular

Great Irish pub with 4 star food. Trivia night/Thursdays is always a fine time. Staff is caring and attentive. Very reasonable in their pricing also. Can't say enough!

Great service. Good food. Love the chicken Parm and wings.

The waitress was friendly but didn't clear the table until asked to do so. The food was great and the atmosphere was inviting.