The Cheesy Chick Cafe & Food Trucks

5385 Main St, Williamsville - 14221
138 reviews
Comfort Food Food Trucks American
(716) 817-9559

Some might call it call it quaint or cozy. Others would find it cramped and horribly cluttered. Almost no matching chairs or tables in the place and, with all the bizarre odds and ends stuffed and scattered about the place, it feels more like a swap meet once in the door. I'm sure it's meant to give more of a nostalgic 'home' feel to it but I found myself more worried of where any or all of it may have come from. The largest of the tables was overrun by personal items of the staff & owner(?) and clearly not for use by the public. The outdoor table seems more for decoration than function. The rest of the tables were cluttered almost as badly. There were so many distractions I didn't even think to do my normal cleanliness check. The single bathroom was slightly cluttered as well but seemed to be well kept for the most part. It's hard to imagine what it looks like now compared to the pictures of what it once was.My better half and I had gone to their food truck at the "Taste of Buffalo". The options we got weren't bad so we tracked them down and gave them another shot. I ordered the Buffalo chicken wrap with a side of mac & cheese with bacon. My better half got a grilled cheese and tomato soup with a Reeses peanut butter tart. She said they were both quite good and wouldn't mind having the recipe for the soup. She's a big fan of tomato soups, so that's saying something. We both agree that the tart was a bit of a darker flavor than expected but turned out to be very nice.I was somewhat less impressed with my order. With all the salad and lettuce hearts stuffed into the wrap it would have been impossible to taste the chicken if not for it being completely drowned in sauce. So much so that it was almost the only thing detectable. Terrible shame because it was actually a good mix. I prefer cooked peppers myself but the ones I got were raw and numerous. I am not a fan of American cheese at all but didn't ask for any changes so as to have it as they make it. It was very cold and seriously detracted from the rest of the flavors. It almost seemed like an afterthought. Not the worst I've had but really not all that great. The tiny bowl of mac & cheese wasn't awful but it wasn't good either. The cheese tasted canned or boxed. The bacon was cooked almost to perfection but, sadly, was just as small in portion and didn't add much to improve. Considering the cost of the meal, and being from a menu for cheese aficionados, it really should have been slightly better.I will give it to the kids working the place. They were very polite and did try to seem attentive to us. One had offered to remake my wrap as the one was torn when being made. A nice gesture that does make an impression.It wasn't as bad as the bad reviews make it out to be but not as great as the the other half tend to tout.I might go back and I'd possibly recommend.

Awesome service! The first thing they asked was whether we needed vegan or gluten free options, super inclusive. Awesome little place!

If you love grilled cheese sandwiches, then this is your place! Always delicious and one of our favorite places to eat! The staff is very friendly and they have fast service. Highly recommend!

The Cheesy Chick staff truly goes above and beyond! We had placed an order on Grubhub and the delivery driver did not leave half of our food. We called to see if it was at the cafe figuring if it was we would go pick it up. It wasn’t and we assured the staff it was fine we would just file a claim with Grubhub. A little while later the staff called us and said they were remaking the food and would drop it off even though we insisted they didn’t have to do that. The food at the Cheesy Chick is always good, but the staff make it even better with their great service and going the extra mile!

First time trying this place and it was awesome. I had the Buffalo chicken wrap and I loved it. Will definitely be going here again! Also super cute little restaurant

This place is AWESOME! It's a super cozy place. The radio station plays good music, the staff is super friendly and the owner is awesome! And the food is AMAZING! They have vegan and gluten free options as well. 10/10 would recommend.

Great staff, great classic grilled cheese, and great classic Mac n cheese

I’m impressed!Lots of Vegan options but these are a must try ??Great service as well ??

BEST CUSTOMER SERVICE. Very good food. The delivery service dropped off the wrong item and would not refund the order, telling me to call the restaurant. When i did the manager (or owner, not sure) immediately offered to re-make the food and re-deliver it to me himself and include extras. I so appreciate the effort and great customer service i received!

Ordered take out from here a couple of times. Macaroni and cheese is great! Love their Philly Mac. Just wish it was baked though. Prices are very fair for what you get. Employees are very friendly. Will definitely return here to try something else from their huge menu.