Cugino's Italian Restaurant

6011 Main St, Williamsville - 14221
245 reviews
Italian Cocktail Bar
(716) 633-8432

The food was incredible and service was outstanding

This is was are first time trying this places and we went there after Matthews graduation and it was amazing!?? The staff was so nice to us and the food was exceptional!!!! I definitely recommend going to this place if you like authentic Italian food because it’s so good???? I got the lobster ravioli and oh my word it was to die for!! Everyone enjoyed their food and we had such a great time there and we would definitely be back!!!!!! I do recommend getting a couple things and sharing because that’s what we did because the portion sizes are a little big here but there are definitely some lighter options if you don’t want to eat too much like veggie pasta and soup. The meatball appetizer is delicious by the way and so is the chicken parm! The pasta is all housemaid and the chicken is organic and it makes all the difference in the world!!!!! I honestly can’t say enough good things about this place The desert is a whole nother level it’s soooo good!!! We got the tiramisu with a chocolate pudding and a cannoli and we all shared it and it was delicious! It was my first time having any of that and I have to say I loved it!!!! We kept joking about hey Matthew can have another graduation next weekend so we can come here again!?

Food was abysmal. Server was extremely sweet but truly could not make up for how awful everything about the food was.

Great food, nice people. Would definitely come back!

The price of the food was way too high for what you get! $38 for a bowl of pasta with a few pieces of shrimp is a bit much! The outdoor area was very cramped and the silverware, table linens and drinking glasses were dirty! Our waitress splashed water all over our feet when pouring our water. The table across from us spilled their ice water all over the table and the waitress came along and cleared off the ice with her hand and flung it across on the ground hitting our feet and then said “what it’s refreshing”…. Overall it is just very overpriced for the food that you get even if it is made from scratch!!

The pasta dish was excellent. The Caesar salad underdressed and way too big. Calamari was good and tiramisu excellent. However it is way overpriced.

We were traveling and found a gem !! One of the best meals we’ve had. The staff were friendly, the chef greeted us personally. The pasta was homemade along with the sauces. Every dish was amazing! We will be back !!!

nothing exceptional about the dinner we had today. Bland food, average service. Did not feel like a high end Italian restaurant. Not returning back!

Our waitress tried so hard and it was appreciated but……..wow, no bartender so we had to walk them through how to make cocktails. It appeared only three persons were on staff thus delays at every turn. Then the food was just ok. We won’t return any time soon.

Food was very over priced and portions were very small. Left hungry.