Just had one of the best pan pizzas I ever had. You have to check them out. They are so friendly and made my pizza just they way I like it!
We were visiting in White Plains and stumbled in to Utica Pie Co. We had one of the specialty pies, it was called the Catherine Street and one of the seasonal salads. Everything was incredible! The place was immaculate and the owner was very friendly and accommodating. He took the time to explain that all the signature pies were named after streets in Utica New York.
I bought several pies for my office! They all loved it- we have been ordering weekly ever since! The owner is super nice. The pies look and taste great!
If you’re driving through White Plains and don’t stop at Utica Pie Co. you’re doing yourself a huge disservice. I had the Utica greens and chicken riggies. They were absolutely outstanding. You could tell this establishment uses high-quality ingredients. Also, check out their signature pizzas (Pies) truly a cut above the rest! (pun intended)
I would call this Pan pizza. It's OK. Not great, not bad. Out of the pies we tired, the white pie was very tasty.Unfortunately, the signature tomato pie was not for us. The cheese they used was very funky. It's possible that's the natural taste of the cheese or it was spoiled, hard to tell. My family and I couldn't tolerate the funkyness of that pie so we tossed it after one slice.The other pies were OK.
I absolutely loved the signature pie! The ingredients were fresh and delicious. I will be making Utica Pie Co. my favorite go to.
Best pizza ever! I feel like i'm back home in Utica!!! Kudos! I plan on returning every time I come to White Plains.
The upside down pizza pie was good, but I really loved the wings. We ordered 10 with medium heat. Wish we ordered 20. I almost placed the order online, but it was going to take over an hour even for pick up. Ended up calling instead and the wait was only 35 for pick up.
Fresh and delicious. By far the best casual dining experience we’ve had. The owner is friendly and the food is great. Highly recommend the pizza, salad and fries.
Awesome Pizza. Was looking for something with a thicker crust, a bit thinner than Chicago or a NY Sicilian and this place hit the sweet spot. Crispy crust, good sauce, not greasy.Good service. Small but clean and tastefully decorated. If it's cold out, they've only got three small tables inside so go for pickup or get it delivered.