I went in to get a take out menu but they didnt have one.. The guy behind the counter said they did and then when he resumed his job I asked the waitress for a menu and she straight up told me no. I dont know if that meant they didnt have it or she just didn't want the business to make money.. Regardless,I should of known better when I saw the fried calamari come out in a Fries basket..
Should have known better than to order a pizza from the only place open past 11pm on a Monday near a college.Extremely thick dough and undercooked cheese which made the pizza soft. Arrived cold, soggy and undercooked.Ate 1.5 slices then threw the rest out.Leaving 3 stars because atleast they got the bacon right!
They deserve 0 star rating because of how disrespect and unprofessional. The lack of customer service is such disappointment because the cooks are really good and have awesome food. But they always have issues with the phone and the delivery is a NIGHTMARE. loved their Tallarin Verde but not worth your money AT ALL.
The Pizza and beef patty was horrible. Both me and husband got sick after eating their food. I like to support local businesses but this is a business you need to stay away from.
Pizza not at all what it used to be, complete trash. They messed up the order, clearly cannot read
I've been going to Nicky's since the early 80s. It WAS the best. The pizza they have there now is cheap and tasteless.The Sicilian was better than NYC... now, I wouldn't eat it if given away. It's all dough, cheap sauce that taste like ragu and imitation cheese...THE SAUSAGE IS CUT UP HOT DOGS.It's really sad to see what these people have done with the best pizza shop in White Plains..DO NOT EAT.
I've been a big fan of Mickey's pizza for the last twenty or so years. Stop tonight to grab a quick slice and I must say the pizza is not the same. I'm surprised it's such a busy area is nightlife spot but the piece I must say was probably close to the worst pizza I've had in a long long time. Don't know what happened but I must say I won't be going back.??
I'm so glad Nicky's is going strong.
I've been coming here my whole life for the Sicilian pie. I picked one up today and it wasn't the same quality. The pizza had a layer of grease on the top and the bottom was burnt black. The end of an era SMH
It was ok, food was good, restaurant was dirty and disorganized. Definitely plenty good if your drunk next door for sure though! I would be willing to try this place again, I'll just have to visit New York again, and I will!