Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

195 North Ave, Webster - 14580
118 reviews
Pizza Italian
(585) 872-2210

Chicken Finger plate was good. Reasonably priced.

Right off the highway and around the corner, Salvatore’s Old Fashioned Pizzeria offers you a wide selection of food! Pizza is out ready to choose from. I ordered the meatball sub that was layered with meatballs and soaked with pasta sauce, cheese added! The bread was cooked to a crisp perfection! There’s no way I would ever be back in Rochester and miss out on this beauty of a restaurant!

I go here a lot and order food for pickup. They are always on time when I pick up my food. Everything I've ordered is great. The garlic bread is amazing. Great gluten free pizza.

Salvatore‘s pizza is the best in Rochester ! ❣️But we decided to try Salvatores subs. I ordered the Italian assorted sub. There were 4 skinny pieces of meat. My boyfriend ordered the roast beaf which had a bit more meat. Won’t be ordering subs again.

I went in for veterans day, sat at the bar, was ignored and left. Will never return to that store.

This place is excellent and very recommend if you happen to be in town??......food was excellent and the staff nothing short of expectations. I live 200 miles away roughly and am super glad I took the chance and stopped in. Pizza selection is amazing!!! I sampled the Manhattan......supreme....chicken bacon ranch....cheese and the old fashioned. My God I would've had more could If I could've fit it in lol........VERY GOOD PLACE

Friendly neighborhood pizza place right? But when I pulled up into curbside and asked if I could have a couple slices and some drinks for my daughter and I because I couldn't come in they proceeded to tell me that I could only use credit card when I had cash on me with a nice tip. I will never in my life give money to salvators again that was ridiculous. Oh wait I'm sorry attempt to try and give them money ✌?

Called to order pizza and asked for curbside pickup, only because I had a sleeping toddler in the car. The guy said the don’t do curbside and he’s never heard of them doing it. Even though I asked why is there a sign outside and parking spots for it. I even told him I’ll pay for the pizza right now and if he can just bring it to my car. He refused and said they don’t do that.

The pizza was all burned and it was sweet.

20 minutes for a salad... not busy. Said they forgot about my order. The Cajun chicken salad was excellent anyway! The chicken had the consistency of a blackened sea bass, delicious! 5 stars if they didn't forget me, a little pricey tho