Barry's Old School Irish

2 W Main St, Webster - 14580
179 reviews
Irish Pub Irish Pubs
(585) 545-4258

We had a great time at Barry's with our two kids! We had the strawberry salad, fish and chips (my favorite!), pretzel appetizer, and my son got the mac and cheese. The staff is friendly, the food is fantastic, and (of course) the beer is great. We look forward to trying out the patio when the weather gets nicer!

We stopped by on a windy day (complete with our puppy) and the folks who served us outside at Barry's were very friendly and very accommodating. Thanks for firing up the fire pit table for us! The food was scrumptious, especially the potato soup... best potato soup I've ever had in my life. Will order it EVERY TIME we're in Webster. Great place for lunch with a real Irish pub feel.

Old school Irish pub. The background Irish music is very corny and outdated. I understand it's for ambiance but I doubt any young Irish people really listen to it these days. Beware it's very loud inside. The food and drinks have improved a lot. The Reuben was fantastic. Everyone seems to have a good time and the bar is known for friendliness.

Burgers were awesome and they had live music. Small but very comfortable atmosphere. Will definitely be back.

My husband and I absolutely love this place. Everyone is so friendly and the food and drinks are delicious everytime. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a nice place to go and also the Guinness pairs nicely with any meal you get there. The atmosphere is very relaxing and comforting.

Nice cozy atmosphere. Great tasting food. Good selection of adult beverages!

We ordered take out at 3:08 and said it was ready at 3:45 which it was and that’s great. We decided on Pretzels and Cheese then 2 Sherpard’s Pie. We were really excited because I am Irish. I arrived and was not greeted by any of the workers. It was definitely crowded Sat Afternoon. I stopped an employee with a pizza and asked where I picked up my order. I approached the bar and got my order. It was $40. We got home and saw that a whole bottom to go container had 3 pretzel sticks and two side containers of beer cheese but the kicker was finding our Shepard pies in soup containers, tiny at that. We had a small portion of mashed potatoes underneath a ton of meat with the even tiniest bit of veggies. It tasted really delicious with the few first bites of mashed and meat stew but after that it was meat on top of meat until the end of the container. Definitely not worth the $14 per person for a to go order. WE WILL NOT BE RETURNING. I’m sorry.

Amazing food - Irish beer on tap - a must!

Don’t miss out on Barry’s Old School Irish. The most welcoming, friendly, comfortable pub ever. One that as a woman dining alone I’d feel very safe. The owners are fabulous. Service is wonderful. The Shepherd’s Pie is delicious. Can’t get enough. The Irish soda bread is beyond. They offer wonderful desserts. The live music and ambiance is wonderful. My favorite spot.

The best potato soup ever!!! My wife ate here with her dad years ago. I've heard about their soup for YEARS... and it lived up to the hype! Great environment and atmosphere. 5 out of 5!