Owner changed the salad menu . Gorgonzola salad with grilled chicken used to have cranberries and walnuts, a good amount of salad greens and Gorgonzola. Changed to no cranberries and no walnuts, hardly any salad greens, less chicken and Gorgonzola and tomato slices with the core. All this cut back and price raised! Will not be going back there!
They Always Charge For MOZZARELLA CHEESE on The Orders, But Out of the Last 6 Orders, They Forgot 4Time To Put it On the Orders, An Incredibly Down Grade in Service Since The New Management Took Over! IM THROUGH WITH THEM!
The pizza is good and the garlic knots are also amazing.
I bought the lunch special: Ziti w sausage and peppers. The price was a about $8. The food was delicious and filling. The staff was courteous. Great location; within walking distance of the LIJ hospital.
Fast delivery. The pizza is always hot.
Good food, good prices, friendly staff. And outdoor tables if you wanted to dine there.
Really consistent quality. The Greek salad is pretty awesome. The only complaint is when we get toppings on half the pizza, the cutting is pretty uneven and my husband seems to always get much bigger slices, which is sad for me because the pizza is pretty darned good!
Had a Sicilian and it tasted frozen and as if someone touched the pizza without washing their hands, it was disgusting
they refuse to accept the coupon. I had a $5 off coupon this Cooper had no expiration date and Jonathan's refused to accept the coupon. Dick coupons from the old menu has no expiration date I presented I told them and they refuse to accept it show now I refuse to accept them and go to them I will find other Pizzeria but I'm just letting you people on Facebook know that John Anthony's is not trustworthy and they don't accept that coupons like I said there is no expiration dates
1st off....delivery over an hour...stuffed mushrooms though good were ice cold....Ala Vodka was dry as a bone even though they were asked to be sure that it wasn't..their bread knots....one uncooked inside the other hard as a rock....will never order from them again ? ?