Terrible Fake Bagels .. definitely NOT Authentic NYC Bagels!!! Owner refused to make me fresh egg whites on a poppyseed bagel. She told me she only had fried eggs that were already premade sitting for hours in a machine. Unacceptable!!! I'm from Long Island...it's all about the water!!! Start importing your water from Long Island or Queens to make Bagels and then you can call yourself a real bagel store!!!
Employees were friendly coffee is okay but the bagel was good! I'd come again:)
They have the best bagels in town, when they are fresh. I swear that the last time we picked up a half dozen, they were yesterday's batch! That was disappointing. Maybe has something to do with not having enough help? I will give them another try in the near future, but Brueggers is always a great alternative!
Good menu options; many bagel choices and sandwich options for breakfast and lunch. Quick and easy even though there isn't drive thru service.
Their bagels are delivered from the Bronx. No wonder they're amazing! Can't wait to go back! Very kind service, too. I ordered the French Toast Bagel with strawberry cream cheese. Also bought everything bagels to go with veggie cream cheese, and they stayed fresh for 24 hours! YUM
I have gone to this place a bunch of times now. Was hoping my poor experiences were one offs, but that doesn't seem to be the case. Let's be clear, the food is pretty solid. But it is overpriced. A breakfast sandwich with two eggs and a hashbrown is almost $10.00. Also the wait is awful, don't go in person. Call or order online. I have not gotten out of there in under 15 minutes ever, from time order is placed to when my name is called. That doesn't even count waiting in line. Today there were two people ahead of me when I ordered, and no one else in the store. The first guy got a dozen bagels and left, the second guy got two sandwiches. From the time I ordered (time on receipt) and got my name called, it was 22 minutes. Again, not counting time waiting in line. Seems like they prioritize phone/online orders. Also, every time I ask that they don't cut my sandwich in half because it is easier for me to eat that way. No matter how I ask or stress it, they still cut in half. They give a sheepish apology about how its habit, if I get an apology at all. Even though it is written on the order slip. Today the woman just laughed and told her employee she cut in half not him, did not even say sorry. Seems stupid and small but my hands aren't great and makes it hard for me to eat. Place is very popular it seems and has recess coffee which people seem to love.
Whenever I’m in town I stop here to pick up breakfast. They have delicious, gluten free, everything bagels, yum!! The staff is very friendly. You can call in an order and pick it up, definitely a good option when they’re busy in the morning.
I like to check out local bagel shops when I travel. Dewitt Bagel Co. is at the top of my list now. The service was friendly and inviting starting with being greeted as I walked in the door. The bagel was delicious. I ordered an Asiago bagel toasted dark with jalapeño cream cheese. They came through for me, especially on the toasting of the bagel, not everywhere does that. They are a win in my book and I will visit next time I’m in town.
Amazing customer service, andbthe closest thing to NYC bagels. Love it!
Awesome service and awesome food! Great first experience. I will be back