The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

1718 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island - 10305
223 reviews
Pizza Italian
(718) 987-2422

Good food friendly wait staff!

The lunch specials are a true bargain. I ordered a garden salad and Veal Milanese.The portions were plentiful. and the food tasted great.A carbonated beverage is included, all for $12.99. The service was excellent and the staff were smiling and friendly.Give it a shot when you are in the area.You will be glad you did.

The food was delicious! Service was wonderful. Looking forward to going back! ⭐⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐

Great food and a great atmosphere! What else do you need to say. It's ???

We keep coming back here for the great pizza. Setting is modest, but attractive. Service is friendly and prompt. The pizza is terrific.

My first New York pizza. Excellent flavor beats any pizza where I'm from that's for sure. The hype is real

We stayed on Staten Island on our vacation to NYC. Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizza was AMAZING!!! We were looking for a great place to try New York Pizza and this place was beyond our expectations. The owner and all staff were polite and friendly. We had pizza our first day and the homemade marinara sauce is out of this world fresh and mouth watering. We actually went back the next day to try the pasta which was also phenomenal and I had the steak cooked perfectly in the brick oven. We could eat here everyday and might just make the trip back from Michigan just to eat here again. ❤️ Highly recommend!!!

Food was very delicious, I liked the margarita pie fresh ! Also got the garlic bread which was amazing ! . Spinach artichoke dip also a good appetizer I would recommend this place for sure

The small square fresh mozzarella with olives was pretty average, I frankly expected a better taste for the souse and cheese. Not bad but way below top iron clad pizzas of NYC. Although this place was a world champion in 2014… I would give it another chance.

Came in to eat a nice dinner with my boyfriend, the owner and manager came out to greet our table and was very friendly! Dana our waitress was attentive, and very nice! We ordered calamari, and a white pie. The food was fresh and phenomenal! This was our first time here and we are definitely returning! This place is amazing !