Cinnamon bagels a little hard. If you want 5 stars on Staten Island you go to Heartland Bagels.
Great bagel store, friendly staff too.
Best Bagels on the South Shore, Hands down !
My favorite bagel stores on the island.
Not sure what has happened to this place but the quality has taken a real hit lately. Was once my favorite bagel store.
Good for you guys at Mikey's! You kind of just got a quick commercial on SNL! Great Bagels and Sandwiches! Worth the ferry ride! Shop Small this holiday season!?⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐If I could give a perfect 7 stars I would. Keep up the good work. Great staff.
Delicious bagel and egg sandwich, staff was very friendly and service was quick.
Excellent bagels.Fast and friendly service.
Specifically call & order :Gutted sesame bagel toastedEgg whites & well done bacon ?-then call back and ask thst they toast the sesame bagel -“sure no problem “Whst you get is totally differentSesame bagel un toasted - not gutted & thry add cheese ?..when yr employees& owners don’t care it’s sad - back to heartland bagels
There are bagels and then there are Mikey Bagels - enough said.