J's On The Bay

1189 Bay St, Staten Island - 10305
197 reviews
New American Pizza American
(718) 720-0922

The food was alright, but the service was incredibly slow. I think the kitchen might have been to blame. Two tables walked out due to the wait. When our food arrived, one of the dishes was a little cold and our Benedict came with the hollandaise broken, which is not the rookie level cooking we expected from this place. I’m surprised they served it to us.

Absolutely FANTASTIC food, love the ambiance/vibe/decor. Such HIGH quality food for a reasonable price. The staff is so friendly and sweet as well. This place is literally one of my favorite restaurants on SI to date. Wow. Don’t believe the other negative reviews. This isn’t your basic boring 2 eggs and toast diner food. 10/10

My nephew treated me to a late lunch. My first time there.Nice atmosphere. My kind of music in the background (classic rock). It was not distracting or loud. Ah the food was yummy. We had mozzarella sticks with a nice dip. Fries just right. My nephew had a burger and I had a chicken hero sandwich. Looking forward to going there again

Beautiful ambiance and decor. Food was exceptional , delicious. Host was very attentive and friendly.

We loved Js on the Bay before its renovation, and now we LOVE it even more! The menu still has the classics, with a bunch of delicious new options. Friendly service, great neighborhood feel, and a wonderful covered patio in the back with an outdoor pizza oven that turns out amazing pizzas in a matter of minutes. The restaurant was closed for a long time during Covid, but it was worth the wait!

Fantastic! They just did a full renovations on this place and it came out beautiful. And best part is the food is still delicious. Started with a warm focaccia bread with some ice cold NYC water to open up the palette. This time we tried mozzarella battens also the Burger and drunken dumplings (dont let name fool ya) its a pasta dish and its off the hook. The vodka sauce was some of the best i ever had. The owner Joe out did himself again. What a great environment perfect for date night or even a quick bite. The wait staff was great George explained some of the dishes. One thing it was lacking was alcohol. I hope soon. But the food makes up for it. We will be back of course.

My son and I went here for brunch this morning and the food was outstanding! This was our 1st time here at the restaurant, we had tried to go there before a few times.... It was always really busy and NOW I know why! When you sit down you're given free minutes croissants with chocolate butter. 1 per person. Delicious.We had the chicken and waffles with sausage gravy, I had eggs and bacon on the best bread, Crispy spinach scattered on the plate. YUM!Best bacon EVER and we ordered a side of home fries. They were sauteed in mixed peppers and were so tasty. wait staff extremely friendly and knowledgeable about the food..My first time here but cannot wait to go BACK!Going next week to check out the dinner menu....

Its finally open for dine-in! We came for dinner everything had a touch of uniqueness and was delicious. The vinegar and salt fries were everyones favourite. The gnocchi was so light and supper tasty. I am looking forward to come during breakfast ?

The place was clean, and besides the deflated balloons hanging from the ceiling, it was a nice decor. The food was fresh, although I like my food served as if it came straight out of the oven, it was ok. The atmosphere was like a neighborhood crowd and friendly. I had the chicken and waffles with vodka sauce it was pretty good. Good food and experience I will go back again.

I got the country fried chicken and waffles, and it was great! Usually I avoid waffles without syrup because I like things extra sweet, but the waffle was a great texture and flavor to satiate my sweet tooth well. The chicken was well cooked, and the gravy was the best thing they could have used to pull it all together!My friends and I were all very satisfied with brunch. We even got muffins and croissants as our free bread. Awesome place!