Carlos Fish Market

3852 Richmond Ave, Staten Island - 10312
93 reviews
Seafood Markets
(718) 967-5758

Normally very good so I won't give a horrible review but if it looks bad please don't bag it up:( no one has money to waste.

The Best Fish anywhere on Staten Island. David is so helpful. He always takes the time to listen and even gives you great ideas for recipes. And his wife is a sweetheart and also very helpful.

Hidden gem on the island. So happy to discover this place. Only took me 25 years of passing it daily to do so. Lol. Fresh fresh fresh fish and shellfish. Owners Dave and Sarah take obvious pride in the business. Live longer...Eat fish!

This is my go to place for fresh fish on Staten Island. They have fresh sushi grade fish daily & amazing soft shell crab! If you were skeptical about where to get your fish on the island then this is your sign to go to Carlos

Been buying my fish here for years. Always fresh and good. Friendly staff too.

I have been coming here for years and years. Never a bad piece of fish. Never a fish bone in any of my lemon sole or cod or even the flounder. Amazing! The best on the island.

This place is fantastic. They have great customer service and high quality fish. The place is always super clean. I cannot recommend this place enough.

Very good variety and always fresh. A little pricey though.

Always fresh fish. A little pricey but worth it for the quality

Omg the best salmon I’ve ever had. Also very good cod fish & try the crab cakes they’re so good. Everything I buy from here is fresh. This store is so clean that it does not smell like a fish store at all. Very friendly owners and staff. I now go here 2 -3 times per week now wish I went there years ago.