We stopped in for lunch and were fully satisfied and impressed. Great appetizers, fabulous French Onion soup, burgers and dessert. We will definitely be back.
Had the most delicious cowboy burger for lunch. Clean establishment with a large menu. My wife and I were so impressed that we may use this place for a small catering family function in the near future.
I need to look into ordering a supply of that salmon with the dill topping, it was absolutely incredible. I attended a bridal shower here and was quite pleased with the restaurant. From the menu to the atmosphere, everything was just lovely. Although I did not try the " fried bread and cheese" dish that was on the table, many were bragging about the taste. I did not have the rolls either but they seemed to be gone quite quickly. Those who decided to order the steak or chicken also seemed delighted with their meals. The folks who were spending time at the bar were happy, friendly, and enjoying their Saturday afternoon. I spoke with a few of the guests and they said that this place was fun and comfortable. I would definitely recommend stopping by and if you wouldn't mind.....please pick up a tray of the salmon for me.
Great service, food was so good. Everyone super friendly. Clean restaurant.Little pricey but worth it.
Went in a week or so ago. Service is absolutely terrible! Our waiter Mike is a jerk! Attitude was beyond unpleasant. This guy needs a class in customer service 101! Food took awhile to come out. He could care less that we waited and when food came out was overcooked and dry. Menu changed and service has gone way down hill. I will not be returning. There's many choices in the area.
All the meals we had there over a two day visit to Long Island were superb! The waitstaff were very genial and supportive of guest's needs. Thank you for helping our family come together ?❤️
Awesome food and atmosphere
Delicious food & excellent service
Hands down the best burger in Smithtown! Delicious ? I am a medium rare kind of girl and I was not disappointed! Service is always outstanding and incredibly friendly. Definitely would recommend a visit, especially if you are into the English/Irish pub vibe.
Friendly service, and tasty food are the hallmarks here. I've always left happy with my experiences at Old Street. Been coming for many years, and will cont6for many more.