Margarita's Cafe Smithtown

581-583 Smithtown Bypass, Smithtown - 11787
243 reviews
Mexican
(631) 257-5999

Delicious and fun! Good guacamole and drinks!

Great food and atmosphere waitress, owner/ manager and maitre d was really nice and welcoming to us private party room looked nice as well various tv's in the eatery, restrooms were squeaky clean place is in the former picolo pizzeria joint which sadly went out in 2014 after many years. Nachos off the hook all of it would return over and over again

Excellent food great service

Always a good experience. Perfectly cooked food and great presentation.

So upset! We have visited numerous times because of good meals, whether at table or bar and throughout the pandemic.Tonight we were excited to introduce my family to our fav place (only a party of 4). Instead, was RUSHED through the meal and asked to wrap up and please leave! We were only there for our appetizer, avocado making and full dinner, for under one hour, 10 min. AND had spent money at the bar prior to our meal. Couldn’t believe the rush out, even with two tables wide open. Unbelievable and so hurt.I am hard to disappoint and am very easy going. This was truly ridiculous. My first non 5 star review.Need to retract my recommendations to my colleagues, family and friends;(

Food was awesome but that cancun margarita? Next level. Drink was on point. This is my new spot. I shop at giuntas and never thought about trying it until now. I'm kicking myself. Waitress was so perfect also i wish i knew her name for honorable mention. It seemed all the staff were friendly. I will definitely be back with friends!

Good, the Passionfruit sangria may be the best sangria I've had. The tableside guacamole was great! Our waitress was amazing. Highly recommend

Food is great, nice size portions

I love this place... the tacos & guacamole are to die for & the decor and atmosphere is great. It’s a perfect date night spot.

We’ve been there a few times. The food & service are always incredible. I highly recommend.