We got a stroop waffle sundae with amaretto custard soft serve and it was delicious! It came with whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry on top, along with hot fudge and caramel in the cup. Perfect for the summer!
Wasn’t very pleased with the service at all. Very rude, very unfriendly. Prices are kind of high for ice cream and food. Plus got the window slammed shut in my face before they where even closed. Not a very pleasant experience will probably not go there again. (6/24/22).
Went to Stella’s for the first time today and had a great experience. Definitely will be going back every time I visit NY. Great prices Awesome customer service Great vibes
awesome icecream service was fantastic the staff was fabulous
Great ice cream and so many different flavors. Friendly family owned business, the owners are always there and are helping their staff and making sure everything goes well. Took my 5 year old nephew there and he was so happy to see that they offered one of his favorite flavors.
A little overpriced in my opinion. The ice cream was good (although expensive for the small amount we got) but I DO NOT recommend getting any food. The fries are bland and the burger was burnt (as well as my husbands). It was all really expensive so it was a bummer! On top of it - We waited about 30 minutes for 2 burgers, 2 small fries and 2 small sundae’s.
Expensive.... personally not a fan of custard. I enjoy a good old fashion ice cream not custard.. They're two different things. Custard and the price is just not my cup of tea.
I tried the Peanut-butter Cup Sunday with Vanilla Ice Cream...A+++ Well worth the trip. I will be back again!
In my opinion, way too expensive. I payed $12 for a hot fudge sundae the size of a babies portion and a medium cone.
Had our first Ice cream of the year today & first time checking out Stella's. The staff was friendly & helpful, taught me that the ice cream is actually considered custard because of the high percent. Was super creamy & the cherry dip was delicious!! We will be back to try other items!! Definitely will have a hard time picking, the menu is huge !