LOVE this pizza. The shop had this cozy welcoming feeling despite the busyness. Highly recommend!
I think this place is terrific. Fresh, tasty, well prepared food every time. And pleasant service. Have been doing take out with them for some time now and am so glad they are in the neighborhood!
I ordered a personal pan pizza with pepperoni. It was so delicious with the right amount of cheese and sauce and not overly cheesy. About 45 minutes later after eating my first pizza and sharing it with a family member I ordered a second pizza pie for delivery through doordash. Marisa was so observative to notice that I had just ordered a pizza not long ago and gave me a free upgrade to a large pizza the second time around for free. Very kind of Marisa and the great pizza making team of Pizzarelli. I am floored and amazed at their generosity but also by the delicious taste of this pizza.This is my new favorite pizza in New York outside of the city.THANK YOU MARISA and to THE ENTIRE PIZZARELLI PiZZA & PASTA Staff!!! Happy Holidays and Best Wishes for the New Year.
My pizza came piping hot and it was so good!
This review is a long-time coming! We order pastas/pizza from here almost every week since before Covid, and the food and service are consistently stellar. We've thought about trying other places but...quickly think why change a great thing! They care about the quality of the food, as well as the people that they're serving. They know the customers, they're personable, and the food is outstanding. The ONE time (keep in mind we've ordered a hundred times over) I called to mention that there was a problem, it was immediately rectified and a new order sent out, no questions asked. Do yourselves a favor and give them a shot - you won't be disappointed.
Wow! We took a chance on this place tonight and everything was delicious. The chicken in my fettuccine Alfredo was deliciously marinated tasty and tender. Someone even went the extra mile to let us know they had to make a change to our order, even though it was an UBER order. Will definitely be a customer again! Thank you!
I tried their chicken bacon and ranch pizza and it was absolute party in my mouth. Went back their in three days with my wife and it was not available, Their team is so amazing- when I asked they made a fresh pie for us- even though we needed only two slices.Absolutely great experience- my daughter had a great experience as well- the chef was so kind to share some dough for her to play.Highly recommend for everyone to try.
Pizza was delicious. I will be back to try a pasta next time.
Excellent pizza. I like them better than nearby Slice of Scarsdale. Staff very nice too; upgraded my small pie to a large for free.
Never in my life would've I have thought that I'd have terrible in the west coast but this please definitely proved me wrong.It like they served me pizza soup unenjoyable and just bad all around. Honestly the worst pizza I've had in ny area.