This is a cafe Rochester should be proud of. Less than 1/2 mile from the Susan B. Anthony House, 1872 was the year of Susan B’s highly publicized act of civil disobedience, her arrest for voting. Women who dared is the theme that is carried throughout the decor and menu. People who lean feminist and progressive will feel in their element. For those who do not, do yourself a favor and get delivery. If I could give this place 6 stars for food I would. The menu is exhaustive with numerous clearly marked vegan and gluten free items in each category as well as options to customize sandwiches with gluten free bread. The person taking my order understood what each distinction meant as well and offered gluten free crackers with my soup - a treat I have NEVER had even at dedicated GF restaurants. I was grew a bit impatient when food took a long time to arrive, but one bite and I quickly realized that the perfection was worth the wait. I suspected that the soup was made to order and not ladled out of a cauldron. I asked about it and it was confirmed. It really makes such a difference. The steak sandwich had slices of 1/8 inch thick filets and was so just juicy enough to moisten the slightly dry gluten free bread. The cheese was lusciously stringy but broke on its own. And the sweetness of the peppers was a welcome surprise, though I could see some not appreciating it.
The best shrimp and grits I've eaten in Rochester hands down not salty seasoned to perfection. Y'all know I'm big on customer service and they didn't disappoint amazing interactions with customers. The music playing in the background is a whole vibe. Definitely will be coming back. Thank you guys for this wonderful experience.
Such a great place with so much flair. Breakfast was very good and friendly staff. The atmosphere is top notch. ?
The food is always freaking amazing here and the service is one of a kind. They have a great menu selection and the service staff are the best hands down.
The food is amazing here and the service is some of the best. They have an awesome menu selection and the service staff are some of the best.
The food is amazing! Shrimp & Grits must try. I almost had everything and never had an issue. The owners and staff are fantastic. I will forever be a fan. ALI
""Tech did not understand system as it is simple and was not dirty at all as it is not used in grease or open flame kitchen (very light use)" - Paul - owner of 1872 CafeHere is a fire hazard at 1872 Cafe of -!GREASE!- covering a non commercial use inline fan before our cleaning service. 1 of multiple fire code issues at this location. Employees, Customers and Upstairs tenants beware of the protentional fire hazard. Duct also does not proper access and needs additional cleaning in the areas which are inaccessible. We will be sending our documentation (Pictures / Field report) to notify Fire Marshall and Health Department.Owner, trying to take advantage of a group of hardworking men to be responsible for his lack of planning and careless neglect. Pictures don't lie but this guy does! GREASE + Non commercial use inline kitchen fan = Fire hazard. Simple logic escapes this one. Obviously avoid.
Ignorant owner who thinks the world owes him a living. Also a health/fire hazard since the ventilation system cannot be cleaned properly. Your lucky if the place doesn’t burn down while your eating.
Delicious food! Fresh ingredients! Got delivery via Uber eats. The cafe made my food much quicker than expected. When it arrived, mac and cheese was still hot. The mac and cheese is very yummy, by the way, would highly recommend. Slices of breakfast pizza the size of my face! Got a crispy chicken salad for lunch, also looks very good. Lettuce is crispy and bright green, tomatoes are not soggy. Very impressive considering COVID food shortages.
Very nice place for a morning coffee/brunch. Nice ambiance, cheerful staff. Nice outdoor seating. Their special coffee/latte are really good. Plenty of options for vegetarian as well. One of my favorite places. Haven’t been able to visit recently though.