No idea where all of these negative reviews are coming from; best pizza in town, especially the crispino slice. I'm kind of suspicious of anyone who thinks their pizza is flavorless lolHands down best italian hero & their gyros are stuffed & delicious.Prices are on par with most prices in the area. Remember we are still in a pandemic. Costs have gone up so all businesses unfortunately need to do what they have to in order to sustain.Pete is awesome, super kind & a big supporter of our schools, sports, kids & community in general -always willing to give. This is our favorite local business to support.
This place totally hit the mark! Slice of pizza, calzone, and meatball hero. The cheese used in the calzone were some of the best I've ever had. All was great. Super nice and speedy service.
Pleasant StaffDecent FoodCash SavingsCould stand area cleanup
Excellent service, good food options, 2 tvs to watch a game or two very friendly staff.
Has been the best and most friendly pizza place for more yrs I can remember
Below average pizza. Buffalo slice was wayyy too much blue cheese and not nearly enough Buffalo. Forgot to take a picture of it before tossing it but here is the pepperoni which was very mediocre. Service was STUPENDOUS though. Only redeeming factor is the workers. FINAL VERDICT: wouldn’t come back. I came for food not great service and average food.
They were good years ago. Not now, the manager is nasty and rude. Delivery person bringing pizza came up on my phone as a scam likely. We will never order from there again. I'm a longtime resident of Riverhead and always used Carlos, but no more!!
So much better pizza within 2 miles
They make decent pizza, they do deliver (or at least they use to,I'm not sure anymore?) The prices are a little high, much like most of the pizzerias these days, and one of the guys I spoke with on the phone once had an attitude that totally turned me off, hence why I don't call for delivery no more..its all good, my money is good anywhere!
Ordered a sausage calzone and it was fresh and hot. Some of the best quality cheese (mozzarella and ricotta) I've ever had in a calzone. Person who took my order was kind and attentive and even brought the calzone to my table. Would come back again!