Best fried fish platters around. This is a hidden gem... An actual fish market that has an indoor/outdoor seating area. I've been here twice and the fried fish basket is amazing... Spaghetti and clam sauce was very good as was the shrimp with Thai sauce/glaze... Yum. Wine and beer selection was decent and staff was friendly. The only disappointment was the whole lobster which I found a little tough. With that said I'd still go back to this place in a second.
I ate at the buoy on Wednesday my sister and I had the fried oyster platter. It was pretty good. However I got the seafood chowder to go. I was disappointed as there wasn't a shrimp, clam, crab, lobster, not anything but a piece of broken fish.I hope the next guest gets a better soup. Seafood chowder. Keep that in mind.
Great food and great atmosphere. Lovely place for a low key date night or to get some food with friends and family. No matter who I bring here there is always something on the menu for them to enjoy, from seafood lovers to people who don’t care for seafood. 10/10 recommend.
Love Buoy One. Nice laid back atmosphere with the best Seafood around. They have the best shrimp cocktail. Everything on the menu from appetizers to the mains and dessert are excellent. Don’t hesitate to stop in.
The bucket of mussels is massive and the white wine scampi sauce is top tier! The staff is always so accommodating with my food allergies and friendly. Overall great seafood spot.
Food was good.Fisherman's platter.Ran out of beer except bottledBut I went there at 7pm so I understand.
The food is fresh and delicious. The waitresses are friendly and highly professional.
Service was ok. Restaurant was an icebox. We were freezing.
Tray of huge fried oysters! Excellent Cobb salad with grilled shrimp! Dog friendly! This will certainly become a go-to place on our trips to and from Montauk
I read all of the GREAT reviews. I ate here once years ago, and wasn't impressed. I thought that I should try it again. They lived up to their GREAT reputation. The food was delicious. Beautiful outdoor dining. Excellent service. I'll be back, and this time it won't take years. GREAT SEAFOOD RESTAURANT!!!