Super surprised Colony Grill has good ratings for Pizza. The crust is thin but tastes like cardboard and is soft. Sauce is minimal and tasteless. Toppings are expensive. They say personal pizzas but is not enough to share with someone or too much to eat by yourself. I not sure why Grill is in the name since they don't Grill anything and all they serve is pizza. Being in the NY bubble there are many other pizza places that are much tastier.
Very good thin crust pizza pie! The service at the bar was excellent. I never heard of Hot Oil before so I had to try it. Spicy Oil would be a better description. It doesn’t affect the crispness of the crust. It just adds a hot & spicy bite to the pie. This is a hidden gem that needs to be experienced at least once in a lifetime. I’ll be back! This is the kind of place that you bring your best friend.
I gave them 2 stars because the atmosphere was nice and the staff was very friendly, but let's be honest, this is a pizza place and the pizza isn't good. I wouldn't even call it pizza. The crust was very thin, so if you like that sort of thing....The sauce was neglligible if there was any at all, and all other topping flavors were drowned out by the "hot oil." I heard a lot of hype about this place, and it certainly was busy on a Friday night, but for me it was total miss!!!
Amazing thin crust pizza. I wish they had a menu that was not just pizza. To compromise I typically always get the Salad Pizza. Restaurant can get very loud at times. Lots of family’s take their kids here. Restaurant is located with a water view
Great pizza, very clean place. Dawn the bartender is very efficient, and always smiling. Also the young man Nikko who is the manger is always very friendly and on top of everything going on in the restaurant making sure everyone is happy with there meals. highly recommend going there.
Great Pizza and Blue Moons On Tap!
Love Colony Grill as a casual pizza spot. Their menu is very very simple - only pizza. Bar pies with a few ingredient add-ons. But we like these pizzas better than most in the area. My boyfriend gets the stinger and hot oil pizza and says it’s a nice heat- not burn your mouth. ?
Good pizza and service. Dine-in or outside on the deck by the water. Parking can get scarce when it's busy. I have been going to the one in Stamford for years. Never a disappointment.
Love the pizza here and the service is some of the best. They make the best pies in all of NY and the service staff are super friendly too.
Super thin crust pizza, plan to eat a whole pizza by yourself. Limited menu of pizza and drinks but reasonably priced. Family friendly, gets loud when busy, overall a fun family night out.