I really enjoyed this pizza, the owner is a funny guy. He was right, it is the best pizza in plattsburg. Will definitely go again
Top notch pizza pie. It's authentic and made with a lot of love❤???
Fantastic pizza at a reasonable price! Glad we discovered New York Pizza. We'll be back!
First time ever going here, definitely won’t be the last. Great pizza, great service.
Amazing pizza and the man making it is so nice. Great place for pizza night
Perfect pizza, great sauce and cheese, dough thin and crispy, all high quality, for most reasonable price,the owner is a good guy only place I go for pies in town.
Best pizza I have ever had eating there again before I leave
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Incredible value and no fuss. Just great pizza. It was so good.
My husband has been going here since forever and I've never been. Well tonight was my first time trying pizza from here and I must say, absolutely phenomenal. Best tasting pizza around! Fresh and homemade. Great price too! If you're up for some great home pizza definitely stop here, it is well worth it.
Been all over had many different pizzas from different states and this is by far the best and freshest pizza you can find homemade from scratch the place it self is clean well kept the owner Bill is fun and friendly and the people that are leaving bad reviews are Karen's and some of them work at other pizza shops that suck and are afraid because New York Pizza is the #1 best Pizza you will find anywhere