Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria

635 Old Country Rd, Plainview - 11803
143 reviews
Pizza Italian
(516) 935-8800

Mario's Ristorante & Pizzeria blew our mind! Our third grade class went on a field trip to Mario's and we couldn't be happier (or stuffed)! As we entered the restaurant, the staff greeted us right away. They all had huge smiles on their faces and seemed genuinely happy to see us. Our tables were ready for us and we were seated right away. We were offered water or lemonade as soon as we sat down. Next, we were given baskets of hot, garlicky, and cheesy garlic knots. Wow! They were delicious. Up next was pizza or chicken strips. If you were really hungry, you could have both!! Let's talk about the pizza. It was served hot. The crust was crunchy and the pizza was cheesy. The chicken was also served hot and crispy, and you need to dip it in the sauce that came with the dish. It was amazing! When we were done with what we had, we were offered more! The waiter was very friendly and was checking on us constantly to see what we needed. He cleaned up all of our plates and napkins as soon as we were done. All of the staff waved goodbye to us and thanked us for our visit. Mario's is the place for you if you love good pizza and good service. Now, hop in your car and go there!

Mario's pizza is the best Italian Pizzeria on Old Country Road in Plainview! Mario's restaurant is clean and bright. There are many windows which allow a lot of natural light which makes the atmosphere warm and inviting. The waiters were so kind and very friendly. They always asked our needs and provided us with the quickest and friendliest service. Our food was brought out to us in a timely fashion. First, we had delicious garlic knots which were warm and garlicy... just the right amount of garlic! Then we had chicken fingers which were crunchy on the outside but oh so juicy on the inside. They even give you marinara sauce to dip! Soooooo delicious! The pizza was so cheesy and the crust was crispy and fresh. Nothing better than a pizza pie right out of the oven. What was even better was that they were so accommodating for our gluten free guest who had his own special pizza and fried chicken. Our lemonade was sweet and refreshing. Our dining experience was thrilling and amazing. We will definitely be going back....soon!

Such a beautiful restaurant! Food was fantastic, service was prompt and courteous too. Owner has a great heart for the community! We will definitely be back

Pizza is awesome, first off. Service is always awesome. We come here all the time to eat in, and we went last night, a super busy Saturday. We did have to wait, which was totally fine, and the staff were audibly discussing with one another that we were waiting and they were trying to get us seated as soon as they could. They kept checking in with us, and did not once seem to forget about us waiting. Our server was super attentive, friendly, and we could see them ALL busting their butts, including the kitchen staff, who were literally running back and forth to bring out dishes. All the servers were communicating, helping each other take large orders to tables, and as chaotic as it actually was, they made it seem so effortless and smooth, and really worked as a TEAM. (Also, that chicken Romano… how I did not know that existed before is a crime) Love coming here!!

Very nice !Food was excellent!Service was A+,!Establishment is well run and well maintained!

Pizza great my girlfriend was there for company party this past Tuesday said food was great .

The food at Mario's was delicious! We stopped in for lunch and was not disappointed. Dessert was delicious. I will definitely be back.

Our favorite neighborhood Italian restaurant. Out of their several locations in the area, we like this full service sit down restaurant the most. Spacious interiors, good noise levels (i.e can hear each other), excellent service. We love the food from Mario's, dining in makes it more enjoyable.

Love this place. Delicious food and nice people.

Amazing food and service. This place is very kid friendly. Will definitely be coming back.