I tried this pizzeria based on a friend’s recommendation and was disappointed with my pizza. It had no flavor to it and I ended up tossing most of it in the trash. Now I understand it may have been the cook having a bad day and I may try the place again but for now it’s a “No Sale” from me.Especially at these high prices.
This was an unexpectedly amazing little gem. Pizza was great and I loved the sweeter sauce. We were visiting from out of town, and were pleased to have found pizza that's a little different than what we have back home. They did not, however, offer their meal deal with plain cheese pizza, only pepperoni, and with a picky kid that was a challenge. But the chicken tenders she settled on were good!
Biked there and got some food, but it's generally overpriced, good pizza though. Would rate 4 but very expensive.
I saw a viral post from Papa Leo's last month, and knew when we came to town from Cleveland we HAD to support them. We were closer to this location, so we didn't get a chance to meet Mack, but we did still stop and grab a pizza to support a small business that values their employees!We ordered the Chicken Parm pizza and it was great!! Definitely recommend!
Their sweet sauce. Is totally sweet and not bad at all. I would recommend going there
Me and my wife ordered from them for our dinner and it was a very bad experience I ordered the Friday fish fry and was so disgusting first the fish was not cooked all the way and the batter on the fish was still uncooked and still wet and the fries were cold and old tasting and no fork to eat the coleslaw and my Wife and she ordered a pizza sub and her sub was soggy and cold and it tasted disgusting as well with a order of fries and her fries were cold and they also tasted disgusting we will never order anything from them again
Awesome subs. Will be back again... Staff was great.
SUB PAPER SUB PAPER SUB PAPER! Most places in Niagara County wrap their hot subs with SARAN WRAP! Pure madness! But not Papa Leos, they know how to wrap a sub for delivery. Food was excellent.
Ordered a veggie sub from Papa Leos Niagara Falls and what a disappointment. For $9.29 plus tax and delivery what a rip off. Stay away from this place.
Great pizza and wings! They have a couple tables if you want to eat in, but I wouldn't really suggest that... most people get it for takeout.