Goodfellas Pizzeria Inc

745 W Market St, Niagara Falls - 14301
170 reviews
Pizza
(716) 285-8448

Very friendly staff and the best pizza!

Soooo good!! Was trying to pick a place for pizza upon our arrival. We made the correct choice!

I've lived behind Goodfellas for years and usually it's a great neighbor. Lately the employees have been hanging around the delivery driveway shooting orbeez guns at each other... whatever they were having fun. But today an employee was outside w a kid shooting off m80s in the driveway right next to the park at the boys and girls club. There were several small children in the park and they were all scared. Some ran out crying thinking there were gunshots. I'm all for workers

I ordered delivery wings and fries with extra ketchup on the side. They said 30 to 40 minutes. After one hour I called and they said the driver will be at my hotel soon. The driver came 10 minutes later with my wings, extra ketchup and no fries. I called to say I didn't get my fries but I just hung up on ignorant woman on the phone. This will be the last time I order from here.

Great wings and pizza! The Honey Garlic wings were phenomenal. It’s been years since I’ve been here, but I haven’t forgotten the name or the food.

The char-grilled wings here used to be amazing!!! WHAT HAPPENED?!?!?! I ordered a large order 2 weeks ago & they were HORRIBLE! Pitiful. Dryyyyyyyy & the meat tasted days old. As expensive as chicken wings are now a days, I was shocked that they served those dried out old chicken wings. This place has gone downhill, save your money and order elsewhere.

This place is just great. Pizza is fantastic, haven't had a bad one yet. Usually get a white pizza with hot peepers, Italian sausage and onions. Try it if you haven't.

The most disgusting pizza and wings I ever had in my life. I called to complain and the woman on the phone was awesome said I had to give back pizza and wings for full refund I told her I'm keeping the drinks and everything was good. They closed up shop at 11 pm. Man showed up different then the delivery driver I gave him the food he asked if he could come in my hotel room for a minute I said no. Asked him if he was the driver of the car he said no he was the owner of the restaurant. He was very intoxicated and said where are the pops.. I said I was keeping the pops..he proceeded to deduct it from my bill. If I was the owner and this had happened everything would have been at no charge. Very very pathetic that he would even show his face in that kind of drunken state..pizza looks like someone took a slice...wings were so dry...it's was the most disgusting thing I've ever tried to eat

Not sure what genius sliced my pizza. That I just picked up there but I hope they do not drive a car

I reported Nancy cause that's a lie. I'm from Niagara Falls canada. Just in love with goodfellas. Had the pizza and wings or just a full tray. Lots of different times when I come over the river. Always the same taste. Always always thank you.