Youngest Brother

310 Robinson Ave, Newburgh - 12550
133 reviews
Italian
(845) 565-3110

The delivery guys have always been very professional and courteous. My first couple experiences were fine and the pizza is delicious, but upon taking out a slice of this pizza I just ordered, I saw a black hair that I pulled out. I totally understand that mistakes happen sometimes, but it was still unpleasant. The restaurant was kind enough to refund my order, so I would probably still recommend them to friends and family.

Exceptional service…the best steak for sure! My husband & I were pleasantly surprised! The quality, portion and price amazing! For $27 a sure steal… other places you would pay $40 at least! Had to do a repeat for lunch today… I woke up wanting it for breakfadt??

Best baked ziti I’ve ever had. Only $14 for a giant portion.

Dinner with mom at Youngest Brother Restaurant. Waitress was very pleasant. Food was awesome. Nice, fresh bread right from the oven. Salad was great (except the olives... I don't like olives). I couldn't decide what to get between the baked ziti, manicotti or stuffed shells so I let the waitress surprise me. The stuffed shells were absolutely DELICIOUS. Only complaint is I'm stuffed (which doesn't happen too often) Even though I'm stuffed... there's ALWAYS room for a delicious slice of tiramisu ??? DEFINITELY a place I will come back to

I had my baby shower here, we rented the side room for 5 hours. Everything was great! Start to finish....NO COMPLAINTS! They were very easy going, food was delish and the waitress (wish I got her name) was very attentive! I would for sure recommend this place for any kind of gathering. :-)

My wife's 60th birthday 9 adultsand 4 children. Food and service wasoutstanding. Special thanks to ourwaitress,Beatrice. She handled ourservice flawlessly and was very kindto the kids.

Their chicken parm sandwich is so good! And the bruschetta is also amazing. The staff is really friendly and they also deliver pretty quick.

I like this place, it’s simple and easy. I stop here quite often for dinner or to grab take out. I don’t know if they got a new chef or what but I stopped in tonight to get takeout (10/28/21) and the food was better than it’s ever been!Everything from the penne vodka to the broiled salmon, the veggies were deliciously garlicky, even the side salad that comes with the meal was so good! I hope whoever was cooking tonight makes my meal next from here!

Pizza was excellent. Didn’t try anything else, would recommend to give it a try!

Went here last night started with the pasta fagioli soup then had a Cesar salad my son had the gyro the hubby had the ziuppa di pesce we like all our food very tasty and good