Friendly service but had to wait over an hour for food.
WORST Restaurant Week meal and experience I've ever had. The inside is tiny. My 6:30 time did not include a seat inside; I sat alone outside (another couple were seated outside shortly after me) in the "courtyard" with a heater on a metal chair with a metal table with plastic utensils, nothing on the table (had to ask for water and salt and pepper), froze (47 degrees), and had a $40 pre fixe meal that was just bad - leek and potato soup that tasted like nothing - not even potatoes; a good beet/goat cheese salad, and a grilled chicken entre with burned grilled chix on guacamole with another salad. My waiter, Samuel, tried his best - comp'd me a short clear plastic glass of wine, but I will NEVER be back to this restaurant. Truly not the "restaurant week" experience I was hoping for. $50 with tip for basically bad pub food. I tipped Samuel 20% - it wasn't his fault, but I will never do this again. Never.I could have had a spectacular meal for the same price in New York City at the Glass House Tavern. This place in Newburgh is lucky I gave them one star.
Loved it!! The food was amazing and it was a great atmosphere. We’ll definitely be back!
Sam and the team at Toasted are amazing. I guarantee any time you walk into this place, you will be getting an excellent meal. The atmosphere is hip, and the backyard is the spot to be in Newburgh on a Friday or Saturday night. I can't wait for the summer to enjoy some more evenings at Toasted.
Great staff and amazing food.
I had the pleasure of visiting this gem. Everyone we came into contact with was professional and friendly. We were there for the last comedy night of the season and my only negative is I just found them now. Would have loved to be able to attend more evening fun. Thank you for the best night out in a long time. We will be back!
I haven't tried their outdoor option because it's cold and I don't trust outdoor heating. It's cozy inside. The food was good and my finicky eater loved his burger.
The staff are so lovely and efficient, the food is super DELISH, and the cocktails are well-balanced. Brussel sprouts and butternut squash soup were exactly what I needed for a misty fall evening. Fried chicken sandwich with fries was perfect. Apple torte dessert was excellent. Highly recommend for lunch and dinner!
Great spot! Staff is super friendly & the soups & Brussels sprouts were so good. The burger was def the showstopper tho—you won’t regret it! See y’all again soon!
Last minute birthday dinner and it was solid.