Pizza Mia

50 NY-17K, Newburgh - 12550
172 reviews
Pizza
(845) 561-1400

I missed my NY garlic knots, & they did not disappoint! (I got 2 orders), & the homemade marinara was amazing. I'll definitely be coming back when I'm on this side of the country.

I DO NOT RECOMMEND Pizza Mia. USED to be my favorite neighbor pizzeria around town, Thumbs up. Now I give it zero stars, THUMBS DOWN!!! When I received my food My grandma slice of pizza was so thin and it was so burnt that I couldn't barely eat it. I ate it because I was starving. The wings started getting almost cold in the middle of my meal. I ate maybe a quarter of the pizza and about three wings. they were very dry and burnt as well. And yes I sorry to the gentleman about the owner treating the elderly very bad. When they first opened he was like that as well. No thank you's.

Best pizza in the Hudson Valley. Very friendly and accommodating staff. I’m a regular here and it’s a nice feeling when you walk in and the owner and staff knows you by name and have your order started before you can even speak the words. It doesn’t feel like your going out to eat at a restaurant. It feels more like home. Thanks Brian and staff!

Flew in on a business trip, staying at the local marriot and i Order a spicy chicken pesto last night and was delighted with how the blend of hot peppers and spices complimented the hearty, light and flavorful pesto. Ive tried ordering from other places and nobody compares, either they cant do it or they chop it up. 5 stars for quality, quantity because it was a healthy plate, & a speedy and covid courteous delivery process. Would recommend 10/10 times to anybody looking for authentic italian food and pizza.

Absolutely disgusted with their food. Worst first experience. Got a chicken bacon ranch pizza and a Buffalo chicken pizza. The Buffalo chicken pizza had red sauce instead of Buffalo sauce, the chicken wasn’t fully cooked through. The chicken on the chicken bacon ranch pizza was raw and had a very funky taste. Went back in to let them know and request a refund. Was very rudely turned away and told that both pizzas were cooked 3 separate times in only 20 minutes. Was told that the chicken was cooked, it was the breading that looked like that.

Amazing pizza!! Great service. In town for work and this was perfect for a quick bite. Had the meatball, and the Grandma pizza. Garlic knots were amazing as well. Definitely going back!!

My ooohhhh my! I would give 10 stars to this restaurant!! By far the BEST VEGAN PIZZA I've tasted! We ordered the meat "haters" pizza & was extremely happy with the pizza! It's not easy to come by such a variety of tasty vegan options but this place has nailed it!! The sauce was awesome, vegan cheese was creamy & gooey, the 3 different vegan meatless toppings were so very tasty!! We will definitely return!

This was seriously the best vegan pizza I've ever had in my life! There's a ton of vegan choices. We got the Italian garlic Philly Cheese Steak and a stuffed pizza. They were both incredibly delicious, from the sauce, to the cheese, to the perfect crust.

Seriously my favorite pizza. The owner is great and the staff is friendly. The pizza crust is so crisp and delicious and there are many creative specialties to choose from. I cannot resist the Caprese but everything is good

Heard a rumor the manager likes to bully elderly patrons. Hope I’m not around when it happens again. Respect your elders, pretty simple. Remember they aren’t alone…