Eddie's Gourmet Pizza

169 S Plank Rd, Newburgh - 12550
76 reviews
Pizza
(845) 561-3333

Eddie's Gourmet Pizza came through in a pinch! I ordered food last min the day before my daughter birthday. He was so pleasant and helpful on the phone! I got 4 pies, tray of penne, meatballs and sausage & peppers. He even got rolls for me and they were so soft! All so delicious! And the meatballs are to die for! I also was to pick the order up the next day and was not able to. I called them 2 hours before the party to ask if they could deliver it and there was no hesitation they said yes. The delivery guy was so nice and sweet. He helped bring everything in and even asked if I needed anything else! Eddie's will be my go to for every party!

Everyone in the area knows this place. Unfortunately it is these older patrons who keep this place running. That said, even some, like my in laws won't go anymore. Their food is nothing short of disgusting. We tried again today and my wife's wrap was full of chicken fat and it had to be thrown out. My chicken was ice cold, had no flavor, was not cooked, looked like it came out of a can and was dripping with white water instead of ranch. Beyond gross. There was only 2 kids working there that looked to be about 16. What a joke! DO NOT EVER GO!

I am writing a review for this establishment because it truly is a wonderful pizza joint!!! However, the only negative aspect of it is that; Eddie's do not deliver prior to "2: o'clock". Although that minor inconvenience, Eddie's is a place you'd go for good quality food and great customer service! I recommend they pizza joint to anyone in or around this neighborhood. MANGIA!!! (Eat up?).

Usually one of the best but Saturdays dont waste your time or money .dont know who they let in that kitchen but they could give 2 Fs about what's coming out of that door ,undercooked pizza and the most disgusting wings I have ever had.

Always fresh hot, fast service

I have say that other people love other places for pizza but for a pretty good sausage and pepper pie, asap, you can't beat Eddie's. The problem with the chains is that everything is so precisely measured and controlled that if they give you an extra slice of sausage on your pie they throw off the corporation's bottom line for a year. Hence everything is shaved and nickeled and dimed. Eddie's isn't like that and the people are nice. In short, a good place to go and they deliver.

gross and tasteless..Basically like overpriced amusement park pizza. Never again.

Yummy ??

Best wings in the Hudson Valley!

I have been coming here for more than 25 years and the food is always excellent