Cosimo's Pizza

1401 NY-300, Newburgh - 12550
29 reviews
Pizza
(845) 564-5144

If you're going to live and work in America learn English! Literally couldn't order because girl didn't speak English.

I’m a regular customer. The steak sizzler is the best. My wife loves the shrimp baguette. The only critique is to bring back the lobster baguette.

Been eating here. Food is 10/10 good. And service is absolutely amazing. I tip everytime, I eat there. No problems at all with waitress. If you been eating there .like almost year they'll found out that what I wanted off the menu there. I have no actual of evidence why this place has little couple of bad reviews. This only just best part of small Newburgh Mall sadly.

Been eating here. Food is 10/10 good. And service is absolutely amazing. I tip everytime, I eat there. No problems at all with waitress. If you been eating there .like almost year they'll found out that what I wanted off the menu there. I have no actual of evidence why this place has little couple of bad reviews. This only just best part of small Newburgh Mall sadly.

The pizza is very good

Dont like the baked ziti. It's nothing baked about it and the pasta taste like they made them this morning and had them sitting out all day. Slapped my food with the sauce together and threw it in the microwave to make it hot... so disappointed. This is my 1st time eating here and might be my last. Maybe next time I'll just get pizza. Stick to the basics.

One of my favorite go-to pizza shops

Been eating here. Food is 10/10 good. And service is absolutely amazing. I tip everytime, I eat there. No problems at all with waitress. If you been eating there .like almost year they'll found out that what I wanted off the menu there. I have no actual of evidence why this place has little couple of bad reviews. This only just best part of small Newburgh Mall sadly.

Food was Good.Nice Friendly Staff.Quick Service.It Was 2 yrs.ago i was there

My pizza had just enough vegetables and spices for my taste and the temperature was just right.